Author: Aren Cambre

  • High schoolers belong in Venturing. These myths keep them in troops.

    High schoolers belong in Venturing. These myths keep them in troops.

    I recommend all youth graduate to Venturing as soon as eighth grade is over, regardless of rank. This aligns the high-school experience with traditional Scouting: their own, age-level program.

    Scouts BSA, a middle-school program, is unsuitable for high schoolers.

    This article addresses myths that cause many to decide against Venturing.

    MYTH: “Venturing is an extra. High schoolers should remain in a troop.”

    Venturing is designed for high schoolers, and it should be their Scouting program.

    Scouting America (SA, and why this is a bad name) does not require troop participation for Venturers. Exception: Venturers who want Eagle must first earn First Class through Scouts BSA (see the myth about leaving the troop and Eagle).

    MYTH: “Younger Scouts need high schoolers to run their troop.”

    Middle schoolers are best served with traditional Scouting: working within patrols to choose where to go and what to attempt, with adult mentorship.

    That is focus of traditional Scouting: the patrol experience. SA’s troop-level roles are not traditional, and they undermine the patrol.

    Patrol programs do not require high schoolers in the room. In fact, accommodating high schoolers in a troop routinely deprives younger patrols of ownership of their own experience.

    MYTH: “Older Scouts owe it to the troop to stay and help.”

    No youth owes a debt of service to a younger age’s program. Just as no sixth grader owes a debt to a pack, no ninth grader owes a debt to a troop.

    “The troop needs you” should never be said. It puts staffing the troop before suitable programming for high schoolers. This can make graduating feel disloyal.

    Helping can still happen, but it must be voluntary. For high schoolers to help with a troop, Troop Guide is the only appropriate troop service role. Like optional Den Chief service, the Troop Guide helps younger Scouts become independent. The choice must be optional, a choice made from that high schooler’s own program.1 (Even better, SA should replace all these with a Guide role.)

    MYTH: “Keeping high schoolers in the troop keeps them in Scouting.”

    SA has struggled to retain older youth since it began in 1910, a problem long known as the “older boy problem“.

    Scouting’s founder, Robert Baden-Powell, also saw this in the UK. To improve, he called for a separate program for older youth. All of SA’s international peers have met this vision.

    SA’s answer has instead been to make high schoolers staff the middle-school program, with a predictable outcome: few high schoolers remain active.

    High schoolers who graduate to Venturing are still in Scouting, in a program built for their age. That is Scouting tradition.

    MYTH: “An older-Scout patrol gives high schoolers their own program.”

    An older-Scout patrol is still part of a middle-school program.

    Its members attend the same troop meetings, share the same expectations, still must pretend to be peers to 11-year-olds, and are still pulled toward instructing and supervising younger Scouts. SA’s own troop guidebook recognizes how this structural mismatch leads to frustration, calling an older-youth patrol a “safety valve”.2 That wording is SA’s admission: a safety valve is supposed to be a last resort to prevent catastrophe. When a safety valve becomes the norm, that reveals a problem is being ignored.

    MYTH: “If a high schooler is happy in the troop, there is no reason to move.”

    Enjoying the troop does not make it a high-school program. Even if some high schoolers like being the most experienced Scouts in the room, they are better served by a program built around their own age.

    Many times, this preference is because a family misunderstands Venturing. Elevate this from fear of the unknown: participate in a crew adventure, allowing a choice between two real programs.

    High schoolers benefit from a high-school program for many reasons, starting with the plainest: They’re in high school. A program built for middle schoolers, however well it’s run, treats high schoolers as younger than they are, and that’s easy to miss when the troop is what we know best.

    MYTH: “Supervising middle schoolers prepares high schoolers to mentor in adulthood.”

    Teaching younger Scouts can provide useful experience. That does not show that teenagers remaining in a younger age group’s program prepares them for adult mentoring.

    Troop roles held by high schoolers mostly involve instruction and supervision, yet they are commonly called leadership, which is different, and often romanticized as mentoring. Instruction teaches a skill. Supervision keeps people in line. Leadership is mutual influence around a shared vision.

    Mentoring is where one person helps another person pursue that other person’s own goals. Mentoring requires listening, respecting choices, and helping without taking over. This is a peer experience: the mentor may know more, but the mentee is an equal whose goals and decisions remain their own. Instructing or supervising younger children does not supply that.

    MYTH: “High schoolers should wait for their younger friends before moving on.”

    A high schooler should not delay graduation. Friends can stay close while spending a year in different programs, just as they do when entering high school in different years. They can spend time together outside Scouting, and the younger friend can join the crew when eligible.

    If same-age friends are staying in the troop, invite them to graduate together.

    MYTH: “If high schoolers lose interest, troop adults need to do better.”

    Troop adults cannot fix the mismatch between high schoolers’ needs and a middle-school program. This Sisyphean quest has been a expectation of adult leaders throughout scouting history, and it’s an unrealistic expectation placed on them by the national organization.

    I call the demand that local adults overcome national’s program-design fault “blame the volunteers”. This blame shifting is unfair to volunteers.

    Encouraging a high schooler to graduate to Venturing is not blaming troop leaders. It frees that youth from a structural mismatch these leaders did not choose and cannot fix. A troop that entirely consist of middle schoolers would be a wonderful gift to adult leaders, as it allows them to focus on mentoring patrols while implementing traditional scouting.

    MYTH: “The troop gives high schoolers the program and leadership experience they need.”

    Older youths’ role in troops is staffing the middle schoolers’ program: teaching familiar skills, running meetings, and supervising younger Scouts. Those duties can teach responsibility, but they should not be a teenager’s main Scouting experience.

    Venturing gives teenagers more room to choose what they want to attempt and persuade peers who can disagree. An office title or age advantage does not secure their cooperation. That tests skills greater than keeping the 11-year-olds in line.

    MYTH: “Occasional older-Scout adventures solve the problem.”

    An occasional trip leaves the rest of the program unchanged. Teenagers return to the same middle-school meetings, same age mismatches, and same expectations.

    Meeting high schoolers’ needs requires a continuing peer group with its own decisions and adventures, with no falling back to a middle-school program.

    MYTH: “A youth should earn Eagle in a troop before being allowed to join Venturing.”

    Eagle is not an entry requirement for Venturing. Youth should join no later than the last day of eighth grade, regardless of rank.

    Age-appropriate programming is essential, not a reward for earning a patch. Youth should have be in an age-level program while pursuing the awards they choose.

    MYTH: “Leaving the troop means giving up Eagle.”

    Youth can complete Star, Life, and Eagle through Venturing. No troop participation is required. The usual requirements and deadlines apply.3 Crew offices count toward requirements for positions of responsibility. Crew adults can help with advancement in the same way troop adults do.

    MYTH: “Venturing has no advancement program.”

    In addition to supporting the path to Eagle, Venturing has its own ranks: Venturing, Discovery, Pathfinder, and Summit. They include adventure, leadership, personal growth, and service.

    The Venturing ranks are available to any Venturer, even those whose first Scouting program is Venturing.

    MYTH: “A serious Scout must keep earning ranks.”

    Venturing implements traditional Scouting: advancement is a method of Scouting, not the focus.

    Advancement is optional. Youth who want adventures and friendships without working on badges are full members. Most of the value of Scouting and the cherished memories come through regular participation, not formal recognition.

    MYTH: “You must already be an experienced Scout to join.”

    No previous Scouting experience or rank is required to join Venturing.

    MYTH: “Ninth graders are too young for Venturing.”

    Venturing is intended to begin when eighth grade ends.4 Youth can join Venturing at 14 or at 13 after completing eighth grade. High school is when teenagers need an age-level program of their own, which is Venturing’s focus.5

    MYTH: “A crew must specialize or focus entirely on demanding outdoor expeditions.”

    Few crews have a topical focus. Typical crews offer a varied program chosen by their members, which is traditional Scouting delivered in an age-level manner for high schoolers.

    MYTH: “Venturing is a career program.”

    Career exploration is in Exploring, a separate program operated by an SA subsidiary.

    MYTH: “Fewer meetings mean a weaker program.”

    Meeting frequency does not measure program quality. Crews typically meet once or twice a month and also have outings.

    With fewer routine meetings, Venturing better fits the lives of high schoolers. This leaves room for schoolwork, sports, jobs, and other friendships.

    Judge the program by the worthwhile activities youth plan and carry out.

    MYTH: “Graduating to Venturing abandons traditional Scouting.”

    Graduating to an older-youth program is Scouting’s tradition.

    Over a century ago, Baden-Powell recognized that older youth were leaving because they were tired of repeating younger Scouts’ tests and games. He envisioned a separate program suited to them.

    All of Scouting America’s international peers separate younger and older adolescents into distinct programs and expect them to move on. Venturing offers that progression within SA.

    MYTH: “Venturing is a social club, not real Scouting.”

    Fun with friends is core to Scouting. Baden-Powell called it “a jolly game” that is also “educative”.6 Also, social experiences are an appropriate support for a high schooler’s development.

    When high schoolers plan their own activity, take responsibility, and learn from what happens, a movie night serves Scouting’s purpose alongside a trip to Philmont.

    MYTH: “Difficulty sustaining crew activities proves the crew is inadequate.”

    When troop events repeatedly take priority, the crew is starved of participants and parent help needed to deliver adventures.

    Ask why the activity fell through: was the plan unappealing or poorly organized, or did families steer commitments elsewhere? Families need to keep crew dates on the calendar for worthwhile plans to happen.

    MYTH: “Venturing is small, so it must not work.”

    Membership totals show how many youth a program reaches; they do not show what it offers its members. Treating the troop as the normal path for high schoolers limits how many youth consider Venturing. To assess a crew, look at what its members plan, do, and gain from participating.

    MYTH: “There is no crew nearby, so the troop is the only option.”

    A crew can be started. The troop’s own chartered organization can also charter a crew.7

    BONUS MYTH: “Order of the Arrow is the fix.”

    Order of the Arrow is a council-operated children’s prestige club that celebrates White supremacy and that I suspect has a perversion problem.

    This prestige club’s main distinctions from ordinary Scouting are its redface minstrel shows and how it tries to convince high schoolers to remain in SA’s middle-school program.8

    This prestige club is not Scouting. Instead, it cannibalizes Scouting, especially Venturing, while falsely claiming to support Scouting.

    Finally, just like older-Scout adventures, once the prestige club’s activity is done, the youth returns to the same meetings, same age mismatches, and same expectations.

    1. For bureaucratic reasons, unlike a Den Chief, the Troop Guide will need to maintain dual registration with a troop. This should be a free, “multiple” registration for the youth. Just as a pack should never expect a Den Chief to pay unit-level dues, the troop should never expect a Troop Guide to pay dues. ↩︎
    2. Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, p. 17. ↩︎
    3. First Class may only be earned through Scouts BSA. Youth who want Eagle and have not earned First Class can still join a crew and remain simultaneously registered in a troop while completing the remaining First Class requirements. Their troop participation has no need to go beyond the minimum necessary to cover those requirements. Once First Class is complete, the youth may choose to continue exclusively through the crew. That said, First Class is a middle-school badge. Venturers who have not earned First Class should seriously consider Venturing’s rank system, which is superior to the path to Eagle. ↩︎
    4. Bryan Wendell, BSA alters age and grade eligibility requirements for Venturing, On Scouting, February 26, 2010. The article supports the ethos of the text the footnote applies to. By opening an option of 13-year-olds who have completed 8th grade, in addition to the standing minimum age of 14, SA is correcting an exclusion of some 8th-grade graduates. This strongly suggests that SA intends for Venturing to start after 8th grade, even though 14-year-old 8th graders can be members. ↩︎
    5. While Venturing membership goes until age 21, this age range is another faulty program design. Beyond the summer after high-school graduation, young adults need to move on. They do not benefit from acting as peers to considerably younger youth, and the younger youth do not depend on their presence. While Rovers is the worldwide Scouting home for young adults, SA killed it in the 1950s. ↩︎
    6. Robert Baden-Powell, Aids to Scoutmastership, 1919, p. vii. ↩︎
    7. Do not allow the crew to exist only in a space allowed by a troop. This undermines high schoolers, conveying that a middle-school program may clobber their interests. Just as packs and troops are seen as independent, the same goes for crews and troops. If a troop has as campout the same weekend as a crew, the crew must not cancel its event because the troop wants high-school supervisors. The middle schoolers will do fine when adults support them in owning their own patrol programs. ↩︎
    8. Several sources attest to that retention of older youth in the middle-school program is among OA’s self-styled distinctions. The clincher is that this retention gambit and its redface minstrel shows are the only parts of OA that are meaningfully distinct from ordinary Scouting. ↩︎
  • Why I believe OA is attractive to perverts

    Why I believe OA is attractive to perverts

    Order of the Arrow (OA), the self-anointed honor society within Scouting America (SA), is a risky children’s prestige club.

    I am concerned that OA’s design and culture create opportunities that perverts can exploit. Historically, this prestige club’s Indigenous fraud and a fake legend put youth in states of undress. Additional sexual assault (SA1) risks include a sprawling participant age range, blurred adult–youth boundaries, secrecy, obstacles to parental observation, and a culture that is averse to criticism.

    All these amplify SA risk. A 2024 study of a random sample of SA’s perversion files identified six “characteristics that allowed motivated adult leaders to molest their victims”. Three of them, “volunteer imbalance”, “reasons for separation from protective adults”, and “social status as a prophylactic defense”, are among OA’s risks that this article reviews.2

    I believe that these are avoidable safeguarding burdens, and SA bears them merely to sustain a prestige club that undermines the actual Scouting movement.

    Why add more risk?

    Kenneth Lanning, a retired FBI supervisory special agent, warns that “certain youth organizations inadvertently provide the child molester with almost everything necessary to operate a child sex ring.” His example is scouting, which offers access to children of a specific age, “opportunities to spend the night with a victim or have a victim change clothing”, and “a system of rewards and recognition, and indoctrination through oaths and rituals.”3

    Scouting already carries SA risk. Why does SA still maintain a children’s prestige club that adds considerable SA risks when this club undermines the Scouting movement and is not essential?

    The OA prestige club is not Scouting. It is not a Scouting program: SA’s Rules and Regulations list the programs, and OA is not among them.4 Also, the prestige club’s relationship to customary notions of Scouting is missing5 or fractured6. No other international Scouting organization has a prestige club. Even worse, this prestige club cannibalizes the actual Scouting programs, devouring time and resources to serve the club’s own interests. Worst of all, the prestige club’s main practical point is to undermine youth by perpetuating a bad program design.

    Before I go on, I need to be clear: I believe the vast majority of the prestige club’s adults care about young people, and they support the prestige club for altruistic reasons. However, caring adults can unknowingly inherit and defend practices that make youth safeguarding much harder. These adults’ good intentions do not make an unnecessary risk necessary.

    Explainers: OA children’s prestige clubs are mainly activities run by local councils, using a brand controlled by the SA national organization. Each council’s prestige-club operation is called a lodge, and councils typically subdivide their prestige clubs into chapters.

    In various places, I refer to the organization and to the movement. The Scouting movement is the activities done by Scout units–packs, troops, and crews. Everything else is the organization, which includes SA’s bloated council and national bureaucracies and everything they do, including the OA prestige club.

    In addition to reasons stated above, OA is not part of the Scouting movement because it is not an activity of Scout units. OA is a children’s prestige club run by the organization that pulls youth, adults, and resources away from the Scouting movement. OA engages adults and youth in activities that serve the prestige club’s own interests while undermining the Scouting movement.

    Undress presented as tradition

    The OA prestige club’s history includes generations of youth performing redface minstrel shows, often while partly clothed. This is not prudishness. The concern, explained below, is undress that OA’s culture expects, not what a Scout chooses for comfort or function.

    These redface minstrel shows fall in two categories. The main shows are pageants where Scouts dress up as stereotyped Indigenous characters as they Tonto-talk through children’s fantasy fiction.7 The other shows are allegedly authentic Indigenous acts that, historically, no tribe has ever authorized OA to use nationally.8 In both cases, OA freely steals Native identity so that it can create theatrical scenery. This is the core of OA’s Indigenous fraud.

    OA’s own account of its first redface minstrel show, in 1915, records Indigenous-derived names from the start: Carroll Edson served as “Sachem”, and the society called itself the “Wimachtendienk”.10 That kicked off a tradition where adults could use “playing Indian” as an excuse to make partial undress seem like an ordinary expectation of belonging.

    Youth in various states of undress at an OA redface minstrel show from 2011 at Old Hickory Council’s Camp Raven Knob, including at least one youth who appears to be wearing nothing but a loincloth. The same level of undress can be observed in 2012 and in 2017.

    As a teenager at El Rancho Cima‘s River Camp in the Sam Houston Area Council, I remember the redface minstrel shows where youth entered the audience to grab new OA candidates. These grabbers appeared to wear nothing but loincloths, similar to some youth in the above video.11

    By 2021, at least Camp Raven Knob’s fire-handling youth was a little less undressed, apparently wearing some kind of undergarment below the loincloth.

    That horrified me. Adolescence was already confusing enough. Now I feared that I might have to perform mostly nude before the whole camp. Fortunately, I managed a path through OA that avoided performing in any redface minstrel shows. That I could avoid it does not make it harmless. The youth who performed were doing what OA’s adults asked of them, in front of the whole camp, in a role OA treated as an honor.

    Others share the same concern. For example:

    Comment
    by u/Logen-Grimlock from discussion
    in BSA

    We see this in other councils’ OA operations, like:

    • A researcher noting a shirtless handicraft counselor at an OA redface minstrel show.12
    • A mom noting that candidates had to remove shirts during an OA redface minstrel show.13
    • A recollection of an OA redface minstrel show participant “with a loincloth and a faux Indian headdress”.14
    A redface minstrel show in Chippewa Valley Council’s Phillips Scout Reservation, including some youth who are partly dressed.

    An earlier example appears in the 1944 footage below, around a decade after SA’s gold loopers15 formally declared OA as an authorized activity, showing teens in partial undress during a redface minstrel show:

    Partly undressed youth performing in a 1944 OA redface minstrel show.

    A 2019 Indian Country Today article described “bare-chested and barefooted” youth dancing in an indoor redface minstrel show.16 In 2015, OA’s national chairman defended shirtlessness during redface minstrel shows by comparing them to swimming activities.17

    Archived 2015 answer from the national OA chairman defending shirtless ceremonies by comparing them with aquatics activities.
    While this 2015 answer now carries an archive warning, it documents the national chairman’s position at the time. I have found no public disavowal of this position.

    That chairman’s comparison misses the point. The concern is undress induced by OA’s culture, where stripping has never served a legitimate function, instead presented as part of belonging to a group. That puts pressure on youth, including youth who are uncomfortable, and that pressure creates an opportunity for perverts.

    An adult “cherish[es]” his OA hazing-ritual experience, where he apparently had to sleep nearly naked. This which was likely in the 2000s. (His comments on regalia are a White-wash of OA’s celebration of White supremacy).18

    I suspect that OA’s apologists may rely on three main points.

    The first apology is that OA is moving away from Indigenous fraud. OA is not getting rid of Indigenous fraud; it’s just adjusting its approach. Redface minstrel shows will continue, and I write more about that below. As long as Indigenous fraud exists in OA, it preserves a vector that perverts may use to induce various states of partial dress.

    Even OA’s current guidance is contradictory. While this club is transitioning some redface minstrel shows to newer versions that have “no American Indian costuming”19, it also supplies attire guidance for redface minstrel shows that has “American Indian attire” as first in a list, with no robust qualification. As this attire is quite often based on stereotypes, defective reads of history, or selective choices of Indigenous attire, OA’s guide perpetuates the mechanism that encourages various states of undress.20

    Historically accurate dress for some tribes, like these Mohave men photographed in 1871, was little more than a breechcloth, so even historically accurate American Indian attire can mean near-nudity, like what is observed in some of the previously cited videos.

    Some will take umbrage, saying that the guidance cited in the last paragraph is obsolete. It is not. OA’s October 2026 manual for prestige-club administrators states, “All principals who conduct [OA’s redface minstrel shows] should wear ceremonial attire that is appropriate and respectful of the American Indian cultures”, offering Scout uniforms or black shirts and pants only as alternatives.21

    A second apology is that introducing girls makes this level of undress harder to continue. Perhaps, but that is circumstance, not policy, and nothing in OA’s guidance prevents a return to it.

    A third apology will be a claim that states of undress are unusual. Even if true, rarity would not answer that concern. The question is what OA asks a young person to accept.

    The future is clear: outside OA’s new induction pageants, the dancing and costuming that have put youth in loincloths can continue wherever a council holds a tribal agreement that allows them.

    Even worse, OA has no required replacement for its most commonly performed pageant, the callout. Each council writes its own callout, and the callout principles in OA’s handbook say nothing about clothing.22 Even though OA alleges that tribal agreements are needed for continued use of Native culture, I have received several reports of continued employment of this culture in councils with no agreement. Also, all existing tribal agreements are so loose, they cannot be differentiated from permissions slips to continue redface minstrel shows.

    We can look at the induction ceremony of the phony Tribe of Mic-O-Say, a different children’s prestige club run by two SA councils23, as a cautionary example.

    This video shows the induction of the phony Tribe of Mic-O-Say at Bartle Scout Reservation (Heart of America Council). Inductees dance in front of the entire camp while stripped to the waist. Several of these youth appear embarrassed. While this fake tribe is alleged to have since made it optional to strip, an adult leader confided to me that in his summer 2026 experience, social pressure to strip remains high.

    While Mic-O-Say is not OA, it illustrates where OA could go. Just create a new story, dress it up with new Indigenous fraud, and once again we get youth dancing half-naked in front of the entire camp. (Did you know that the Northern Arapaho Tribe told Mic-O-Say to knock it off?24)

    It’s not a stretch to suspect that perverts prefer youth who wear less clothing.25 SA’s perversion files have an example of someone who allegedly SAed an OA youth who was changing (was in a partial state of undress) to prepare for a redface minstrel show. Another perversion file conveys that an ejected adult asked to remain involved with the specific part of OA where youth would change clothes and often be partly undressed (SA rejected the request; the request itself is what is notable). Another file tells of a man, known for heavy involvement in an OA dance team, who was convicted of SAing several youth. (Incidentally, when perverts maneuver children into changing clothes, they “almost always succeed in seducing them”.26)

    NOTE ON THE PERVERSION FILES: The SA perversion files concerning adults, which became public through litigation, are an incomplete and difficult-to-interpret historical record.27 They contain allegations, administrative decisions, and, in some cases, accounts of admissions or criminal proceedings.

    They are widely called “perversion files” because SA’s own bankruptcy brief says that files about sexual misconduct were originally designated “P” files, for “perversion”.28

    A file’s existence is not a finding of guilt. Some files concern multiple people. The examples here illustrate particular incidents and institutional responses; they do not measure the prevalence of SA in OA or establish its rate relative to other SA activities.

    Also, the public adult files cannot characterize youth-on-youth SA. A national U.S. study found that juveniles committed most of the SA reported against youth in its sample.29 (That study is also cited in a Time magazine article.30) That finding concerns the broader population and is not an SA- or OA-specific estimate. Surprisingly, only around one in eight of SA’s perversion files cover youth-on-youth incidents.31 It is not possible to discern why SA’s ratio of these files wildly contrasts the study.

    A sixth grader and a college junior in one “youth” category

    SA’s training identifies age differences as a concern in youth-on-youth SA:32

    The concern makes sense. Differences in age, maturity, experience, and power can leave a younger child vulnerable to an older participant. As large age gaps amplify this risk, an organization should have a compelling reason to build large age gaps into its ordinary activities. SA does not.

    It is unusual to discover youth organizations that don’t use narrower age bands. Girl Scouts has grade-based levels33, and non-school youth sports commonly divide participants by grade or age34. Middle schools commonly cover grades 6–8 and high schools grades 9–12.35 Clubs and well-run church activities are typically split like schools.

    SA’s international Scouting peers have programs that average to about three years each:

    This is sound. It’s not just about reducing SA risk. As I explain in Scouts BSA: a middle-school program unsuitable for high schoolers, narrower age bands also let a program focus on a recognizable developmental stage, and they honor the vision of Scouting’s founder.

    With its weirdly wide programs, SA departs from customary wisdom. Scouts BSA’s 8-year age range packs 10-year-olds through 17-year-olds in the same program. Venturing (and Sea Scouts36) includes 7 years, extending from 14 through 20.37

    OA is worse: it places 11-year-olds and 20-year-olds in the same “youth” category!

    OA’S WEIRD DEFINITION OF “YOUTH”: OA treats participants under 21 as “youth” for its activities.38 An 11-year-old39 sixth grader is in the same participant category as a 20-year-old college junior, a 10-year range spanning three development phases! Calling this range “youth” neither makes them developmental peers nor promotes safeguarding.

    To its credit, OA’s own age-policy page explicitly says that SA’s youth-safeguarding adult rules apply to OA’s “youth” members starting at age 18.40 But the problem remains: SA’s own rules require tent-mates to be no more than two years apart and recommend buddies no more than three years apart41, and its training warns that youth offenders tend to target children three to five years younger. SA believes modest age differentials are an abuse risk, yet it allows an unnecessary children’s prestige club to define a 10-year range as peers! While the Barriers to Abuse can be enforced around that mismatch, it is asking a lot of that complicated, unfocused ruleset to compensate for an unnecessary, weirdly wide activity design. I consider that dangerous.

    SA’s perversion files describe cases where perverts are alleged to have taken advantage of OA’s weirdly wide age range. In one file, a mother alleges that a 19-year-old OA Chapter Chief, whom her 15-year-old son met through an OA lodge, groomed the boy and then turned his attention to the boy’s 12-year-old brother.42 It is not normal for a 19-year-old to be close friends with a 15-year-old. The parents wrote that the friendship had seemed unusually intense, but they had put it down to shared activities, including the man’s OA office.

    When adults are like peers

    OA blurs another boundary: all members, regardless of age, share much of the same membership journey.

    OA’S PRESTIGE LADDER: Entry into OA’s prestige ladder starts when a youth or adult–yes, both 11-year-olds and 50-year-olds–are selected in a popularity contest.43 They are both publicly announced in the same callout, a redface minstrel show recognizing selected candidates.44 Both complete the ordeal, a hazing ritual involving silence, limited food, work, and sleeping apart from other campers45. (Note: A newer hazing ritual that is allegedly softer is now rolling out46, but OA’s manual for prestige-club administrators celebrates “exhilarating fatigue that comes from working hard with very little food” on the same page where it prohibits hazing47.) After adults and youth complete the hazing ritual, both wear the same white sash bearing a red arrow48. That sash indicates one’s level on OA’s prestige ladder, where youth and adults both progress through the prestige ladder’s Ordeal49, Brotherhood, and Vigil rungs.50

    While OA formally assigns adults advisory responsibilities, in my experience, its shared rituals and language of “brothers” create an unusual sense of adult–youth equality. As a boy, I felt the weirdness without understanding why it deserved questioning. People today report the same dynamic to me.

    The safeguarding issue is whether that culture makes an adult’s responsibilities unmistakable. Soccer coaches neither become team captains nor play alongside their youth team members. Teachers do not earn classroom grades alongside their students. The lines are clear in those settings. As OA’s adults participate in the same prestige ladder as children, OA blurs lines between adults and youth.

    Research gives us reason to question that arrangement. The Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse in England and Wales found that institutional cultures normalizing over-familiar adult–child relationships could allow SA to develop without raising suspicion.51

    Sandy K. Wurtele’s paper, Preventing the sexual exploitation of minors in youth-serving organizations, explains that adult–youth relationships carry an unequal distribution of power and responsibility. Adults must maintain boundaries and avoid using youth to satisfy their own emotional needs. She also identifies treating a minor as an adult or equal as a possible boundary violation.52

    Wurtele’s examples of boundary violations are clear misconduct, such as supplying alcohol, so sharing a prestige-club pageant is not equivalent. But applying her principles to OA nevertheless raises pointed questions:

    • What is the boundary? Within this shared system, where is the adult’s distinct duty made unmistakable? When participants of all ages wear the same sash, call each other “brothers”, and go through the same prestige ladder and associated pageantry, the boundary between adult and youth roles is blurred.
    • Whose needs does the activity serve? It is fine for Scouting adults to experience adult friendships, adventure, and the satisfaction of mentoring youth. But an adult’s desire for status or belonging must never compete with a child’s needs. Why build that into the design, by allowing adults to do the same rituals and prestige ladder?
    • What makes troubling closeness stand out? Grooming often develops through apparently ordinary interactions.53 When shared experience and unusual familiarity are normalized, adults and youth may lack clear grounds for recognizing and challenging a boundary crossing.

    The age-policy distinction already illustrated why a written safeguard is only part of the answer. Culture determines how people apply it. Australia’s Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse put institutional leadership, governance, and culture at the center of its first child-safe standard.54 Citing SA’s youth-safeguarding rules does not answer the concern of how OA’s everyday culture wears them down.

    The alternative is a warm relationship with an unmistakable adult duty. Scouting’s founder, Robert Baden-Powell, described the adult leader as an older sibling who sees the younger child’s point of view while carrying a distinct responsibility to guide and, when necessary, be firm:55

    …the Scoutmaster has to be neither schoolmaster nor commanding officer, nor pastor, nor instructor. All that is needed is the capacity to enjoy the out-of-doors, to enter into the boys’ ambitions, and to find other men who will give them instruction in the desired directions, whether it be signalling or drawing, nature study or pioneering.

    He has got to put himself on the level of the older brother, that is, to see things from the boy’s point of view, and to lead and guide and give enthusiasm in the right direction. Like the true older brother he has to realise the traditions of the family and see that they are preserved, even if considerable firmness is required. That is all. The Movement is a jolly fraternity, all the jollier because in the game of Scouting you are doing a big thing for others, you are combating the breeding of selfishness.

    Note the word older. This distinguishes the roles. While Scouting’s founder prescribes a meaningful, warm relationship, he also conveys a clear adult duty.

    That older-brother standard is the distinction OA muddies. Shared experiences and honors obscure the adult’s different responsibility.

    The perversion files give an example where a youth, who wrote that he was SAed multiple times by an adult, wrote how one time he was SAed at a place relevant to the Vigil rung of OA’s prestige ladder, not long before the youth was to ascend to the same prestige-ladder rung. In another case, a man in his mid-50s, who was employed by a council, admitted to a sexual encounter with a youth during an OA overnight activity, and the file describes him abusing at least two youth at OA events, including section conclaves. That adult later pled guilty to SAing a child.

    Fraudulent prestige discourages hard questions

    OA’s false claims to be sacred, authentic, and honorable do more than flatter its members. They can make scrutiny itself seem offensive. Two forms of fraud sustain that prestige.

    Indigenous fraud

    The Indigenous imagery described earlier does more than furnish costumes. It lets OA stake a fraudulent claim to authenticity and virtue.

    The stolen imagery invokes the “noble savage” stereotype: Indigenous people imagined as inherently virtuous and close to nature.56 OA appropriates that virtue for its own profit, a form of stolen valor. With little exception, it’s an enduring fraud.

    OA’s published policy sets deadlines for revised rituals that are based on new children’s fantasy fiction that avoid Indigenous themes. But cleaning up some redface minstrel shows does not address how OA’s culture was formed by 111 years of cultural theft. And OA makes clear that this culture will be continued. Nearly every council’s OA lodge and chapters tie themselves to fraudulent Indigenous identity by naming themselves with stolen Indigenous words,57 and OA expressly permits councils to continue this form of Indigenous fraud.58

    While OA now requires councils to obtain tribal agreements for some uses of Indigenous culture, such as live performances, my review of OA’s tribal agreements explains how the arrangements can preserve the redface minstrel shows. National oversight is part of the problem, as discussed later.

    Those continuing names and redface minstrel shows preserve the stolen valor that OA’s new children’s fantasy fiction was supposed to leave behind.

    Honor-society fraud

    Personal honor is already fundamental to Scouting. Consider the first point of Baden-Powell’s original Scout Law59:

    1. A Scout’s Honour is to be Trusted.

    If a scout says “On my honour it is so,” that means that it is so, just as if he had taken a most solemn oath.

    Similarly, if a scout officer says to a scout, “I trust you on your honour to do this,” the scout is bound to carry out the order to the very best of his ability, and to let nothing interfere with his doing so.

    If a scout were to break his honour by telling a lie, or by not carrying out an order exactly when trusted on his honour to do so, he would cease to be a scout, and must hand over his scout badge, and never be allowed to wear it again—he loses his life.

    First point of the original Scout Law, from the 1908 edition of Scouting for Boys, by Robert Baden-Powell, showing how the concept of honor is core to Scouting identity.

    Scouting itself is an honor society! Honor is the starting obligation of every Scout, not an exclusive status conferred by an internal prestige club. (Important note: I do not stand behind Baden-Powell’s words on obedience. They show unresolved tension between developing independent character and demanding deference to authority.)

    OA’s branding as an honor society60 encourages an unjustified distinction between ordinary Scouting and a supposedly more honorable inner circle. This is snobbery and elitism, which Scouting’s founder opposed. For example61:

    4. A Scout is a Friend to All, and a Brother to Every Other Scout, no matter to what Social Class the Other belongs.

    Thus if a scout meets another scout, even though a stranger to him, he must speak to him, and help him in any way that he can, either to carry out the duty he is then doing, or by giving him food, or, as far as possible, anything that he may be in want of. A scout must never be a SNOB. A snob is one who looks down upon another because he is poorer, or who is poor and resents another because he is rich. A scout accepts the other man as he finds him, and makes the best of him.

    “Kim,” the boy scout, was called by the Indians “Little friend of all the world,” and that is the name that every scout should earn for himself.

    Fourth Scout Law, by Robert Baden-Powell

    In other writings, Scouting’s founder repeatedly rejects snobbery and treats fellowship as something shared by every Scout. Separating oneself into a prestige club that’s gated by a popularity contest and that falsely claims generic Scouting values as its special domain opposes a key ethic Scouting’s founder expected of us.

    Return to the selection process described earlier, this time asking what it establishes about personal honor. Meeting eligibility requirements and winning a popularity contest are not the same as possessing exceptional moral character.

    This popularity contest, formally called an “election”, is almost always conducted in SA’s middle-school program. The middle-school ages are where children start to learn how to navigate status and social interactions. In that life stage, popularity and peer conformance have outsized value. While that is normal in their developmental stage, it reduces this election to a middle-school popularity contest.

    People from my father’s generation have shared stories of this popularity contest neglecting deserving Scouts. I have my own from my youth. I have seen it in my sons’ cohorts, and it has been repeatedly shared with me and in social-media forums. In those experiences, the middle-school popularity contests function as expected.

    Prestige becomes protection from scrutiny

    OA’s Indigenous links and claims to honor can turn criticism of a practice into an accusation of disloyalty.

    In 2023, I published a leaked, secret letter from twenty-five recent national and regional youth officers calling for an end to Indigenous-themed activities. That the letter reached the public only through a leak illustrates the climate I am criticizing. In OA-enthusiast communities, including but not limited to the Save the OA group on Facebook, I have repeatedly seen reform advocates castigated as disloyal.

    That reflex matters for safeguarding because the loyalty that shouts down critics of the institution can also discourage questions about its members. Lanning’s analysis, quoted earlier on access and ritual, also identifies loyalty to the leader and group as a means of manipulation. They are among the features of Scouting’s bonding mechanism that “can all be used to control, manipulate, and motivate victims.”62 OA concentrates those features.

    That raises a practical question: what happens when an apparently worthwhile activity discourages closer scrutiny? In one of SA’s perversion files, a parent alleged that a man used OA work as an excuse to lure youth to his home, where SA and alcohol use were alleged to have taken place. The adult was “known to [a reporter] to be frequently inviting Scouts to spend the weekend”. Why did that go on for so long without questioning? (Per a letter from a county official, the adult “will receive treatment for his problem while being restricted from working with children.”)

    Even the trappings of OA’s Indigenous fraud are valuable to perverts. For example, one of SA’s perversion files conveys that an adult, who was known for improper conduct in OA, allegedly lured youth to his home partly by constructing a phony Indigenous sweat lodge.

    Secrecy is part of the culture

    OA’s secret-society mystique has deep roots. Its connections to Freemasonry help explain some of OA’s pageantry.63 To be clear, this is not a criticism of Freemasonry. Adults are free to join private societies, and I reject extremist, conspiratorial views of Freemasonry. However, importing that mystique into a children’s organization raises different questions.

    OA’s own history records a 1921 committee report saying the ritual had been revised because “meddlesome outsiders” had gained access to it, and urging that copies be limited to three, with all others destroyed.64 Its membership pledge, called the Obligation, referred to secret rites and symbols until a 1935 revision.65 Historical redface minstrel show booklets also document restrictions on access decades later.66 As a youth, my peers and I experienced the result of OA’s pervasive secrecy: due to information embargoes, we had little understanding of OA’s activities or meaning before induction.

    The secrecy is not merely historical:

    • OA’s redface minstrel show scripts remain password-protected. The access instructions rely on insider knowledge.67
    • OA’s October 2026 manual for prestige-club administrators prohibits photographs and video recordings of induction, Brotherhood, and Vigil pageants. Its justification of continued secrecy is thin, claiming it protects the participants’ concentration and the pageants’ atmosphere.68 Combined with OA’s barriers to parental observation (more below), this ban obstructs outside knowledge of OA’s pageants.
    • Outside observers still encounter the secret-society identity. For example, the 2019 Indian Country Today report cited above put that characterization in its headline.69
    • Extreme secrecy has made reform hard to follow. Reform information followed the pattern of the 2023 letter: an induction document leaked in 2025 and participant reports from a 2025 meeting were the first credible sources of information about the revision of OA’s redface minstrel shows, many years after the process allegedly began70.

    A culture of secrecy creates numerous risks. An example risk is that a purported secret rite can borrow credibility from the surrounding culture. A perversion file describes such a ruse, where someone, who later pled guilty to SAing youth, presented sexual acts as entry into a supposed hidden OA group. While this pervert’s act was probably not related to an OA redface minstrel show, it illustrates how a pervert could exploit a child’s expectation that OA has secrets.

    Parents need permission to observe

    SA’s Barriers to Abuse states a straightforward rule:71

    All aspects of the Scouting program are open to observation by parents and leaders.

    “Barriers to Abuse Within Scouting” section of Guide to Safe Scouting, Boy Scouts of America, 2003. The same language appears in the current Guide to Safe Scouting.

    Curiously, the next item on that page prohibits “secret organizations”.72 These are requirements, and they have no further qualification. (OA’s own handbook mentions the Guide to Safe Scouting as “a mandatory source for all OA activities and meetings”.73)

    OA nevertheless tells parents to expect barriers to observation. In 2014 and 2018 articles, its national chairman disallowed parents from attending, conveying that nonmembers must not observe OA’s redface minstrel shows beyond the public callout. Parents with concerns were directed to the lodge adviser (the top volunteer bureaucrat over a council’s OA operation), then were directed to access a script and training video. After all that, parents could seek an exception from the Scout Executive, the council’s CEO and most senior commissioned bureaucrat.74

    The dates make that rules-versus-practice problem concrete: the 2018 response came at least 15 years after the parent-observation rule!75 This reveals that OA’s cultural dynamics let it openly flout the Guide to Safe Scouting‘s Barriers to Abuse! The Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse, cited earlier, found the same gap in other institutions: “contradictions between safeguarding policies, which made certain conduct or behaviour unacceptable, and institutional norms and practices which tolerated the behaviour”.

    The same secrecy-first framing appeared in Cradle of Liberty Council’s parent guidance as of September 2026, which defended the “Experience”76 and directed concerns to the lodge adviser.77 That contradicts the plain and unqualified language of the Guide to Safe Scouting. Cradle of Liberty Council’s isn’t just any old council. Its lodge is OA’s founding club. Similar language appears on pages for Natchez Trace Council78 and Greater Tampa Bay Area Council79.

    While the above-mentioned 2014 and 2018 articles are disclaimed as archives, I cannot locate any newer articles by OA that change this guidance. In fact, in its latest manual for prestige-club administrators, OA advises that attendance at the Brotherhood redface minstrel show is limited to those on the Brotherhood and Vigil rungs of OA’s prestige ladder80, which likely excludes most parents.

    This contrasts mightily with the middle-school program’s guidance on parental presence, which asks a parent who wants to watch a troop meeting only to tell the Scoutmaster in advance so the visit can be arranged.81

    Effective barriers to abuse are crucial to SA’s survival. OA acts differently.

    Separation from the home unit means parents cannot assume that the familiar friends and trained adults from their child’s Scouting community will be present.

    An example of plucking youth from their support networks is the members-only culture of my own council’s winter-camp staff, which is run by my council’s OA operation. Because staffing required OA membership, a Scout’s friends who were not in OA could not staff alongside him. In the 7 years I staffed this camp (2018-2024), council volunteers obsessed over winter-camp staffers being current on OA dues82, and they withheld crucial information from staffers whose OA dues had lapsed. All this even though winter camp is a council program for all Scouts, not an OA activity.

    These examples raise access concerns: procedural hurdles for parents and membership conditions that can separate youth from familiar peers. Perverts benefit when fewer informed adults are watching and when children are separated from their friends.

    One of SA’s perversion files tell the story of an adult who allegedly selected a youth for special treatment at an area OA event83. The file alleges that this resulted in the youth receiving explicit instructions on S&M acts. If parents could have observed, could that have happened? The chapter-chief case discussed earlier adds a related warning: the mother initially understood the unusually close relationship through the participants’ shared OA roles. Another perversion file, about a man later convicted of forcible SA, alleges a youth was pulled into a room alone at an OA event, then SAed. Had parents been able to be present, would this have happened? And in yet another alleged SA incident, a file conveys that an OA ordeal provided cover for an adult to remove two kids from the event, ply them with beer, and then SA one of them throughout the night. (After evicting the man they believed to be a pervert from an event, the event’s officials asked him to come back to transport his victims home. While this is hard to believe, I don’t think it is SA’s current practice.)

    A national committee that will not confront its own failures

    OA’s national committee should be the place where these contradictions are resolved. Instead, its terrible record gives little reason for confidence.

    The history already described leaves national administration with a question: why were these practices allowed to continue for so long? OA has engaged in redface minstrel shows since its earliest years. In the 1910s, its original redface minstrel shows would likely not have been understood to be harmful. However, the federal government formally ended its centuries-long, White-supremacist, tribal-destruction campaign in the 1970s84, switching to tribal self-determination. OA ignored this pivot, and over five decades later, OA still celebrates White supremacy by perpetuating its Indigenous fraud. That long history makes national administration’s delay harder to excuse.

    The delays continued after formal reform began. The pageant revision discussed earlier is also a test of the committee’s ability to carry an announced change through to completion. Revising OA’s children’s fantasy fiction should just take a few months, but this committee instead has dragged this revision through 5-6 years, with very little transparency until a “ta da” moment. Even worse, it’s not done. More revised children’s fantasy fiction is forthcoming.

    The tribal-agreement problem becomes an oversight problem here: how does the national committee check what councils have actually obtained permission to do? Despite being richly staffed85, and despite only four councils having tribal agreements86, this committee neither reviews tribal agreements nor requires their disclosure, simply relying on council attestations that an agreement exists.87 This “trust me, bro” approach has a predictable outcome: all tribal agreements so far are just open-ended permission slips for councils to continue redface minstrel shows.

    A large national committee should be capable of examining the substance of such an essential reform. Why settle for mere assurances from council activities whose longstanding pattern of behavior demands oversight?

    This is unserious administration. As an example, OA’s AIA Policy page can’t even get history right, claiming that the 1830 Indian Removal Act is from 1810.88 And it offers different dates for retiring of the current redface minstrel shows: first quarter 2025; June 1, 2026; and July 1, 2026.89 In fact, as of press time, the redface minstrel shows may continue through mid-2027, with that deadline softened as “likely”.90

    Prestige plays and rewards for loyalty–the norms for gold-looper volunteer appointments in a captured organization91–impact willingness to challenge defective practices. If this children’s prestige club’s national administration is too lazy to review four tribal agreements, how can it be trusted to assure youth safeguarding?

    OA cannibalizes Scouting

    OA is not Scouting. It is not young people practicing the Scout method through their own units. It is a separate prestige club within SA, with its own honors, pageants, and events.

    OA’s core is its council-run activities, which do not replace the continuing experience of Scouts planning, undertaking, and learning from unit-level adventures together through the patrol method. Being an activity of the organization does not make OA part of or a substitute for the Scouting movement.

    Even some adults removed from Scouting treated OA as separate from it: One person asked to remain in OA after removal; another’s lawyer sought permission for OA publication work during his suspension; and another appeared at an OA Ordeal after an earlier exclusion.

    Beyond those safeguarding concerns, OA cannibalizes the Scouting programs it claims to support. Its activities compete for young people’s time, adults’ effort, and resources that could strengthen troops and Venturing crews.

    OA’s retention strategy creates a deeper conflict. OA’s 2024 mission announcement identified a “specific commitment to retention” in SA’s middle-school program.92 But who is being retained? High schoolers. OA believes it may be “the only place where a 14 or 15 year old has the opportunity to lead his or her peers as opposed to younger Scouts”.93 OA’s 2025–2027 business plan goes further, seeking to make OA the “retention driver for all older youth” in SA.94

    That is an admission of a program-design problem. As I argue in my examination of Scouts BSA, that program is a middle-school program despite its age eligibility extending through 17. High schoolers need a continuing experience built around their own interests, growing independence, and relationships with peers. Occasional OA events do not repair the everyday mismatch of lingering in a middle-school program.

    SA already has an older-youth program: Venturing. It provides homes in which high schoolers can pursue adventure, service, and leadership alongside peers. Those experiences should be central to their Scouting lives.

    Instead, OA offers an additional social circle and older-youth activities while encouraging continued participation in Scouts BSA. Where that combination satisfies a teenager’s desire for a peer community, it weakens a central incentive to join a Venturing crew. OA squats in the space that SA’s actual high-school programs need to attract members and sustain active units.

    That is the cannibalization: OA competes with troops for participation while helping preserve their dependence on high schoolers. At the same time, it draws demand away from the programs that could give those high schoolers an experience of their own. SA can point to OA as its answer to the older-youth problem, enabling it to never address the obsolete, dangerous design it imposes on its Scouting programs.

    What does OA provide in return that requires maintaining this separate institution?

    Central claims seem to be camp service, peer friendships, and leadership opportunities. Those benefits deserve to survive. But councils don’t need the OA brand to organize camp service opportunities. Crews can provide age-level friendship, adventure, and leadership experience to high schoolers. None of this needs a children’s prestige club to claim them as its special territory.

    Even the service defense needs scrutiny. In my experience, OA’s main camp-service contribution is labor performed during the hazing ritual.95 How much of that work is useful is unclear. Some is certainly work of minimal value or make-work concocted to give the ritual a purpose.

    I have heard several accounts of work being withheld from equipment operators so that initiates would have something to do, and of holes dug only to be filled again. During my own time as an elangomat (a guide during the hazing ritual), I supervised adults spending hours on manual work. The camp tractor could have done some of it in minutes; other tasks were low-value work, and some of that effort could instead have provided meaningful service opportunities for Scout units.

    Comment
    by u/openwheelr from discussion
    in BSA

    Another account is where hazing-ritual participants “took tents down that then were decided to be too wet and had to put them back up to dry and without other things to do”, with “fourteen year olds .. [who were] very hungry sitting in silence”. Yet another account is of a council-level volunteer bureaucrat, who observed “service projects [that] were meaningless” at some hazing rituals.

    The institutional problem is clear: the prestige club’s ritual needs work to do. This incentivizes concocting labor to give the hazing ritual purpose, then SA cites that labor as a reason to preserve the prestige club. This is circular. Hours worked are no substitute for useful results.

    A council’s insistence that its camps need OA-branded service raises a separate question: are those camps economically viable? Volunteer labor can be a legitimate part of a sustainable camp, but a claim that the camp cannot survive without a children’s prestige club is a warning sign about the camp’s operating model. Councils should be able to explain how attendance, fees, donations, staffing, maintenance, and eventual replacement of facilities fit together, and why useful service cannot be organized through regular Scout units or other volunteers.

    SA’s own camp accreditation framework calls for assessments of camps’ contributions to council financial sustainability and plans addressing programs, staffing, attendance, finances, and facilities. If child labor is being used to prop up a camp whose needs exceed the resources the council can reliably sustain, preserving a children’s prestige club merely papers over that problem. The council still needs to fix the camp’s finances. A need for camp labor does not establish a need for a children’s prestige club.

    The bargain is perverse. SA accepts the additional safeguarding burdens described above, devotes resources to a prestige club that distracts from the mission, and then uses that club to compensate for a program design it should repair. In my assessment, OA helps sustain the very mismatch that its older-youth activities promise to relieve.

    OA’s worthwhile activities do not require OA. SA should put those opportunities into the regular programs, where they can strengthen the Scouting movement instead of cannibalizing it.

    Retire OA and fix the programs

    OA has no indispensable purpose that justifies its bargain. It forces SA to accept unnecessary safeguarding burdens while diverting attention from a better, safer program progression.

    The prestige problem also has a parallel in SA’s own training. Years ago, youth-protection training warned about perverts who sign off on advancement a child had not earned: unearned approval could be used to gain trust and weaken resistance. SA should recognize its own institutional parallel. It keeps “signing off” on OA’s fake claims–honorable, sacred, traditional, essential–the very claims that make OA harder to question.

    But questioning OA is what we must do. A prominent OA gold looper was taken into custody by police during a predator-vigilante sting, though the district attorney later declined to prosecute.96 In response, someone who had also recently been an OA gold looper made a stunning observation about OA’s culture and seriousness:

    SA must stop apologizing for its children’s prestige club and start solving problems with these steps:

    1. Publicly apologize for OA’s 111 years of celebrating White supremacy. With its Indigenous fraud, OA’s entire history is premised on the success of the USA’s multi-century, White-supremacist, tribal-eradication campaign. As mentioned above, the federal government grew a moral backbone in the 1970s, so this apology is over five decades late. SA must publicly apologize for the racist sins of its children’s prestige club. It must apologize for undermining tribal soverignty.
    2. Kill the OA zombie. Liberate this prestige club’s worthwhile activities to Venturing, an actual Scouting program, and let councils continue camp service without the OA brand, without cannibalizing the very Scouting programs councils are chartered to support.
    3. End dangerously wide program age ranges. Make Scouts BSA a middle-school program for grades 6–8. Move high schoolers into Venturing, and refocus that program on grades 9–12. Create a Rovers program for young adults, giving them an experience of their own, where they are finally treated like adults.
    4. Stop using cross-age interaction to excuse a bad design. Keeping high schoolers in a younger program is not essential to Scouting, is not a historically grounded model, and is not conducive to youth leadership development. That said, an age progression need not end older youths’ contribution to younger Scouts. We can offer voluntary, cross-age-service roles such as the Guide role I propose.

    SA’s obligation is to deliver high-quality Scouting to the young people it serves. The survival of a children’s prestige club does not belong ahead of this.

    Footnotes

    1. SA means both Scouting America and sexual assault. It is mind-boggling that SA’s national organization chose a new corporate brand in 2024 that initializes to SA, right after concluding a record-setting, SA-related bankruptcy. ↩︎
    2. Mitchell B. Mackinem, Deborah Laufersweiler-Dwyer, “A Deeper Look at the Boy Scouts of America ‘Perversion’ Files: Structural Factors Related to Access and Abuse“, Journal of Interpersonal Violence, August 2024. ↩︎
    3. Kenneth V. Lanning, Child Molesters: A Behavioral Analysis for Professionals Investigating the Sexual Exploitation of Children, 5th ed., National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, 2010, p. 76. ↩︎
    4. In SA’s Rules and Regulations (Oct. 28, 2025), the Scouting programs are identified at the top of section VII: “Cub Scouts, Scouts BSA, Venturing, Sea Scouts, and Lone Scout”. Notably, Order of the Arrow is mentioned nowhere in this document. ↩︎
    5. A key example, but far from the only one, is that the patrol method, which OA lacks, is the “one essential feature in which Scout training differs from that of all other organizations”, according to Scouting’s founder, Robert Baden-Powell (this quote appears in various editions of his Aids to Scoutmastership book). ↩︎
    6. An example, but far from the only one, is the lack of any personal progression in OA, which is an essential part of Scouting. While OA has a prestige ladder–Ordeal, Brotherhood, and Vigil–the first and third steps are just popularity contests, and the middle step is built on mumbo jumbo. ↩︎
    7. OA is currently transitioning to new ceremonies that resemble Dr. Seuss-inspired mindfulness workshops. While writing new children’s fantasy fiction should take a few months, it has been going on for 5-6 years and remains incomplete as of publishing of this article. ↩︎
    8. This refers to OA nationwide. In response to recent OA rules, some local tribal agreements are known to exist, but they are all flawed. ↩︎
    9. From a Facebook post titled “Order of the Arrow Tap Out Ceremony”. ↩︎
    10. First Ceremony, Order of the Arrow, Boy Scouts of America. Per OA’s own history, Carroll Edson served as Sachem at the 1915 redface minstrel show, and the society took the name Wimachtendienk, a possibly mangled word of the Delaware people. Together they signal that “playing Indian” was with OA all the way to its founding. Some may defend this first redface minstrel show as being less of a minstrel show than what OA later evolved to, but the important fact that makes it a minstrel show is the use of stolen Indigenous theming. ↩︎
    11. I mean the redface minstrel show participants who went into the audience to bring forward newly selected candidates. This description is my recollection of the redface minstrel shows I witnessed. ↩︎
    12. Michelle Denise Farley, “WIMACHTENDIENK, WINGOLAUCHSIKM, WITANMEUI : Use of Native Culture in the Order of the Arrow“, December 2007, p. 9. ↩︎
    13. Calling Out Ceremony, West Texas Scouting History. This is Mrs. J. C. Gibson’s account of Otena Lodge’s calling-out redface minstrel show at Camp Billy Gibbons, where her son was inducted in 1976. ↩︎
    14. Stallion Cornell, “The Order of the Arrow“, September 16, 2007. ↩︎
    15. “Gold loopers” refers to professionals and volunteers associated with SA’s national organization. While most gold loopers are productive and committed to the Scouting mission, they are beset by the national organization’s self-dealing culture, its ambivalence about competence, and its disinterest in the Scouting movement. The net effect is a national organization that is constantly screwing up and that has permitted neglect to pile up for decades. “A bad apple spoils the bushel” is the best analogy, and the SA national organization has many bad apples. ↩︎
    16. Vincent Schilling, “Order of the Arrow is a ‘secret’ scout society ‘in the spirit of the Lenni Lenape’ – a Lenape leader disagrees“, Indian Country Today, September 16, 2019. ↩︎
    17. “Ask the Chairman – Should ceremonies be conducted shirtless?“, Order of the Arrow, Boy Scouts of America, October 7, 2015. ↩︎
    18. This comment is by Facebook user Justin Irwin in the Order of the Arrow Members group on Facebook. That he participated in the hazing ritual in the 2000s is a guess based on his apparent age in photos. ↩︎
    19. New Induction Experience Frequently Asked Questions, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    20. Approved Attire for Order of the Arrow Ceremonies, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    21. Handbook for Officers and Advisers, Order of the Arrow, October 2026, p. 26. ↩︎
    22. Ibid, p. 26. “Each lodge should develop its own call-out ceremony.” ↩︎
    23. Tribe of Mic-O-Say, Wikipedia. ↩︎
    24. Demand letter from Northern Arapaho Business Council, April 15, 2026. ↩︎
    25. Max Taylor, Gemma Holland, and Ethel Quayle, Typology of Paedophile Picture Collections, The Police Journal, Volume 74, 2001. On p. 101, in Table 1, is a set of classifications of child-porn images preferred by pedophiles, ranked by severity. It is notable that all levels’ “Description of Picture Qualifies” includes a possibility of a photo having an element of partial undress, full nudity, or visible undergarments. Also, the lowest level, “Indicative”, includes non-erotic and non-sexualised pictures of children in their underwear or swimming costumes, so even ordinary images of partly dressed children turn up in these collections. ↩︎
    26. Kenneth V. Lanning, Child Molesters: A Behavioral Analysis for Professionals Investigating the Sexual Exploitation of Children, 5th ed., National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, 2010, p. 58. ↩︎
    27. Mitchell B Mackinem, Deborah Laufersweiler-Dwyer, “A Deeper Look at the Boy Scouts of America ‘Perversion’ Files: Structural Factors Related to Access and Abuse“, Journal of Interpersonal Violence, August 2024. Notable is that of a random sample of 400 cases, only 140 had “retrievable data”. ↩︎
    28. Debtors Information Brief, February 18, 2020, p. 85 (of PDF, which is p. 20 of an “Introduction” section). ↩︎
    29. Ateret Gewirtz-Meydan and David Finkelhor, Sexual Abuse and Assault in a Large National Sample of Children and Adolescents, Child Maltreatment, May 2020. ↩︎
    30. Elizabeth Letourneau, Luke Malone, “America Has Been Going About Stopping Child Sex Abuse The Wrong Way“, Time, Feb. 15, 2023. ↩︎
    31. Debtors Information Brief, February 18, 2020, p. 54. This is a filing in SA’s bankruptcy. “This dataset contained files involving 6,878 (88.0%) Adult IVs, and 941 (12.0%) Youth IVs” ↩︎
    32. Understanding and Preventing Youth on Youth Abuse, Boy Scouts of America, p. 7. ↩︎
    33. Girl Scouts uses grade-based levels, although multilevel troops exist. ↩︎
    34. While the typical norm in team sports is same age, it is possible for younger youth to “play up” on an older team. As a recreational soccer coach, I have encountered limits on “playing up” that kept the total age range within roughly three or four years, which is inside American norms. ↩︎
    35. Grades 6–8 for middle school and 9–12 for high school are common American arrangements, with local variations. Sharing a school does not mean every age participates together in every activity; grade-based classes and ordinary social patterns further shape contact. ↩︎
    36. For this article I will use “Venturing” similarly to the national organization, to describe both the Venturing and Sea Scouts programs. Both programs are designed around the high-school experience, although they, too, have excessively wide age spans. ↩︎
    37. See SA’s Scouts BSA age-eligibility information. Also see the age ranges for Venturing and Sea Scouts, which are the same. Scouts BSA serves ages 11–17 with generous exceptions to include age 10. As crossovers from Cub Scouts to Scouts BSA happen during 5th grade, and those are the main source of new Scouts BSA members, the assumption is that a considerable number of 10-year-olds join troops. Venturing serves ages 14–20; while 13-year-old 9th graders may also join, I still use 14-20 for this comparison for two reasons: 1. 13-year-old 9th graders are unusual nationwide (with some regional exceptions), and 2. unlike 10-year-old 5th graders, the 13-year-olds in Venturing or Sea Scouts are in the same school level the programs are designed around: high school. ↩︎
    38. Q/A: Age for OA Activities, Order of the Arrow, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    39. OA’s membership requirements for youth include registration, qualifying camping nights, a minimum program rank, unit-leader approval, and a popularity contest. Thus an 11-year-old who satisfies those requirements is eligible for OA. As we have 11-year-olds who earn the Eagle rank (examples: Reston and Camarillo), and Eagle’s requirements exceed all OA requirements except for the popularity contest, we may assume that OA’s minimum age is no older than 11. ↩︎
    40. Q/A: Age for OA Activities, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    41. Youth Protection and Adult Leadership: Scouting’s Barriers to Abuse, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    42. This perversion file includes the testimony of a parent who appears not to be deeply familiar with SA’s structures and activities. While the parent does not explicitly state what kind of event this was, how she describes the event fits the mold of an OA event. Even if it was not an OA event, OA symbology factored in the story, and she conveys that she declined to question this weird relationship partly due to this man’s OA office. ↩︎
    43. Youth members who meet some rank and camping requirements are selected for OA initiation by a middle-school popularity contest that almost always takes place at a meeting of the middle-school program. While SA encourages high schoolers to linger in its middle-school program, most high schoolers ditch SA or barely participate, so votes in these popularity contests are dominated by the middle schoolers. The main pathway for adults to be selected for OA initiation is a popularity contest of the unit committee, with no further requirements. ↩︎
    44. A callout publicly announces candidates selected for membership. Many traditional callouts used the Indigenous-themed performances criticized here, although a newer callout, that feels more like a Dr. Seuss-inspired mindfulness workshop, is gradually replacing the redface minstrel show version. A callout is distinct from the subsequent induction redface minstrel shows, which are also gradually being replaced. ↩︎
    45. OA’s membership page describes the hazing ritual as involving silence, small amounts of food, hours of service labor, and sleeping apart from other campers. It applies to youth and adult candidates. While OA claims to prohibit hazing, this claim is absurd given these plainly stated realities of this ritual. ↩︎
    46. A new version of the hazing ritual is rolling out, with a plan to be fully rolled out in summer 2027. This new hazing ritual keeps the hours of labor but appears to replace some parts, like the isolation, silence, and scant food, with non-Scouting elements that resemble mindfulness seminars and faux-religious workshops. ↩︎
    47. Handbook for Officers and Advisers, Order of the Arrow, October 2026, p. 25. ↩︎
    48. The OA sash is a white band bearing a red arrow, worn across the uniform. It has markings that indicate one’s status on OA’s prestige ladder. ↩︎
    49. The word “ordeal” describes both the hazing ritual for initiates and the bottom rung in OA’s prestige ladder. ↩︎
    50. While OA describes Ordeal, Brotherhood, and Vigil as membership honors, they are just a prestige ladder. Both youth and adults ascend this ladder. Ordeal is gated by a middle-school popularity contest, Vigil is gated by an OA-insider popularity contest, and Brotherhood is where the member does some silly exercises at least six months after joining OA. ↩︎
    51. “Seven Key Research Findings“, Child sexual abuse in contemporary institutional contexts, Independent Inquiry into Child Sex Abuse (a “statutory inquiry for England and Wales, established in 2015 under the Inquiries Act 2005” (source)). ↩︎
    52. Sandy K. Wurtele, “Preventing the sexual exploitation of minors in youth-serving organizations,” Children and Youth Services Review 34 (2012), 2442–2453; available online September 28, 2012. See especially sections 5.2–5.5, pp. 2449–2450. An author’s copy appears in these conference materials. The paper supplies general prevention principles; the application to OA is my analysis. ↩︎
    53. Elizabeth L. Jeglic, Georgia M. Winters, Benjamin N. Johnson, “Identification of red flag child sexual grooming behaviors“, Child Abuse & Neglect, February 2023. The research explains why apparently ordinary interactions can be difficult to distinguish from grooming. Since OA encourages adults to participate in children’s activities, my concern is whether OA makes adult responsibilities sufficiently clear and troubling closeness sufficiently recognizable. ↩︎
    54. Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Final Report: Making Institutions Child Safe, Volume 6, Commonwealth of Australia, 2017. ↩︎
    55. Robert Baden-Powell, Aids to Scoutmastership. This is Baden-Powell’s guide to adult leaders. While it has various publication dates, this passage is largely intact among them all. ↩︎
    56. The noble-savage stereotype romanticizes Indigenous people as innately virtuous and close to nature. The criticism here concerns OA’s use of that stereotype, not Indigenous people or their traditions. ↩︎
    57. Review the list of lodge names in OA Lodge Compliance, the data behind the Order of the Arrow cleanliness audit. Nearly every name steals from or parodies Indigenous words. While this is only a list of lodge names, ethics for naming chapters are assumed to reflect the ethics of the lodge. ↩︎
    58. Per AIA Policy, Boy Scouts of America, “There are no changes required to lodge or chapter names, totems.” ↩︎
    59. Robert Baden-Powell, Scouting for Boys, 1908, p. 49. ↩︎
    60. “The OA is Scouting’s National Honor Society.” About [Order of the Arrow], Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    61. Robert Baden-Powell, Scouting for Boys, 1908, pp. 49-50. ↩︎
    62. Kenneth V. Lanning, Child Molesters: A Behavioral Analysis for Professional Investigating the Sexual Exploitation of Children, 5th ed., National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, 2010, p. 76. ↩︎
    63. S. M. Adkins, “Freemasonry, Scouting and the Order of the Arrow“, The Phoenixmasonry Masonic Museum and Library. This is provided as one of many credible examples tying OA to Freemasonry. ↩︎
    64. Grand Lodge Changes Ceremonies, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    65. OA Obligation Timeline, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    66. Ceremony Booklets, Order of the Arrow. “Safeguarding” in this historical discussion is OA’s use of the word to refer to restricting access to redface minstrel show texts. Currently, SA uses “safeguarding” to refer to practices that prevent SA. ↩︎
    67. Ceremony Texts, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    68. Handbook for Officers and Advisers, Order of the Arrow, October 2026, p. 26. The “May 2021 Revision” label elsewhere on the opening pages belongs to the reproduced SAFE material, not the handbook edition. ↩︎
    69. Vincent Schilling, “Order of the Arrow is a ‘secret’ scout society ‘in the spirit of the Lenni Lenape’ – a Lenape leader disagrees“, Indian Country Today, September 16, 2019. ↩︎
    70. In the “The National Order of the Arrow Committee could care less” section of OA’s pretendian core ceremonies celebrate racist oppression, mock tribes, must be blown up, I publish a 2023 email substantiating that by then, the revisions to the redface minstrel shows and children’s fantasy fiction had already been going on for two years. ↩︎
    71. Youth Protection and Adult Leadership: Scouting’s Barriers to Abuse, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    72. Ibid. ↩︎
    73. Handbook for Officers and Advisers, Boy Scouts of America, October 2026, p. 4. ↩︎
    74. “Ask the Chairman – Non-Members at Ceremonies“, Boy Scouts of America, August 6, 2014. “Ask the Chairman – Ordeal Guests/Parents“, Boy Scouts of America, January 24, 2018. While the pages include an archive disclaimer warning that information may have been superseded, I cannot find any newer material that changes these practices. ↩︎
    75. This language does not appear in what I believe to be the 1999 or 2001 editions of the Guide to Safe Scouting. It may be new to 2003. Regardless, this language was added no later than 2003. ↩︎
    76. Yes, “experience” is capitalized in the original text. 🤷‍♂️ ↩︎
    77. Parent Info, Unami Lodge, Cradle of Liberty Council, September 20, 2026 (while the archive.org link is from July 2026, the statements concerning secrecy were on the page when it was accessed by the author on September 20, 2026). While this page does not expressly forbid observation, it defends secrecy and routes parents’ concerns through the lodge adviser instead of inviting them to watch. That falls short of the plain and unqualified openness the Guide to Safe Scouting requires. ↩︎
    78. Newly Elected Candidates, Natchez Trace Council. ↩︎
    79. Parent Info, Greater Tampa Bay Area Council. ↩︎
    80. Handbook for Officers and Advisers, Boy Scouts of America, October 2026, p. 27. “Only Brotherhood candidates and Brotherhood and Vigil Honor members may attend” the Brotherhood redface minstrel show. ↩︎
    81. Parent Involvement (About Scouts BSA), Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    82. Even though SA members already subsidize SA’s bloated bureaucracy with steep annual member fees, the children’s prestige club charges an additional annual fee. ↩︎
    83. In SA, “areas” were groupings of several councils. OA runs area-level events called “section conclaves”. These conclaves represent triple separation from the home, district, then council, then area. Partly courtesy of SA’s rapidly shrinking membership, the former system of areas and regions (regions consist of multiple areas) has been consolidated into a system of territories. ↩︎
    84. The most notable date may be President Richard Nixon’s July 8, 1970 special message to Congress on Indian Affairs, where he declared that the “policy of forced termination [of the federal trust relationship with tribes] is wrong”. ↩︎
    85. National Order of the Arrow Committee, Boy Scouts of America. This page reveals a huge committee. In addition, SA has several more volunteer bureaucrats associated with the national organizaiton within each of its 16 territories, titled “Section Adviser” or “Associate Section Adviser”. ↩︎
    86. Given OA’s longstanding problems with secrecy and Indigenous fraud, the only tribal agreements that will be acknowledged as existing are ones that are public or for which the basis for existence goes well beyond “trust me, bro” from a council representative. ↩︎
    87. AIA Policy, Boy Scouts of America. The attestation is referenced here: “Lodges will attest to having an agreement or not annually as part of the recharter process.” No other practice is outlined. A confidential source has discussed this with a gold-looper who is part of the National Order of the Arrow Committee, and the gold looper claimed that this large committee lacks the resources to review council tribal agreements, even though only four are known to exist as of press time. ↩︎
    88. Ibid. ↩︎
    89. Ibid. ↩︎
    90. New Induction Experience Frequently Asked Questions, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    91. Thanks to captured governance and self-dealing of the commissioned-bureaucrat patronage system, the cultural norm is that gold-looper appointments–volunteer or professional–are mainly for those who have spent years prostrating to the bureaucrats’ patronage system. The goal is to maximize appointments to those who fit the mold of feckless bureaucrats, discouraging those with leadership skills or competence. The main results are incompetence and inertia. ↩︎
    92. Announcing the OA’s New Vision, Mission, and Purpose, Boy Scouts of America, July 18, 2024. ↩︎
    93. Ibid. ↩︎
    94. Order of the Arrow: 2025 – 2027 Business Plan, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    95. New Induction Experience Frequently Asked Questions, Boy Scouts of America. It characterizes the current hazing ritual as where “candidates are on strict silence and spend most of their time toiling”. ↩︎
    96. A predator-vigilante group live-streamed the sting and posted about it on X. In the archived video, the man makes several statements about online exchanges with an actor posing as a teenage boy, and he is then handcuffed and led away by police. The district attorney declined to prosecute. I am not naming him or linking these sources because they name a man who was not prosecuted; archived copies of the sting videos are on file with the author. ↩︎
  • Venturing: the most traditional program in BSA

    Venturing: the most traditional program in BSA

    Venturing1, a program designed for the high-school live stage, is BSA’s (why I don’t like SA) most traditional Scouting program.

    Why Venturing is traditional

    (The video above has additional detail beyond this narrative.)

    Why “most traditional”? Of all BSA’s programs, Venturing comes closest to the original vision of Robert Baden-Powell, Scouting’s founder, and to the reasonable evolution embodied in international Scouting practice. Examples:

    Additionally, Venturing is part of a continuous chain of senior-youth programs dating back 112 years.

    Scouts BSA is a middle-school program

    Your high schooler doesn’t have to be stuck in Scouts BSA, a middle-school program that has infantilized high schoolers for 116 years.

    BSA “engages” high schoolers by saddling them with babysitting chores and making them staff a corporate-bureaucracy simulation. This arrangement is peculiar to BSA. It displaces the patrol method. It also substitutes bureaucratic roles for genuine leadership. This design is contrary to the founder’s vision, and it causes BSA to lag decades behind international peers.

    None of the familiar arguments for holding high schoolers back in the middle-school program holds up to scrutiny. They are just excuses to kick the can down the road on BSA’s obsolete program design.

    Your high schooler deserves a high-school program

    BSA has spent 116 years trying to solve the “older-youth problem” while insisting that these older youth stay in a middle-school program. This is institutional incompetence. If an obsolete model has failed for 116 years, competent institutions try better ideas.

    Parents must value their child’s development over BSA’s obstinance. Reject the obsolete program design, rip off the band aid, and move your high schooler to Venturing.

    High schoolers do not belong in a middle-school program. They are as deserving of age-level programming as any other group in Scouting. (And middle schoolers do not depend on being supervised by high schoolers. They will do much better owning their own experience, with adult mentorship.)

    Find a crew today at beascout.scouting.org. If you cannot locate a crew, contact your council about starting one!

    1. In BSA norms, the word “Venturing” is both the name of the actual program and a collective noun that includes Sea Scouts. Venturing and Sea Scouts are sibling older-youth programs serving the same age range. Sea Scouting, which has a nautical focus, was administratively part of Venturing from 1998 until 2016. ↩︎
    2. The traditional patrol method is simply an emphasis on teams of youth owning their own adventures. While “patrol method” is used to describe how the middle-school program, Scouts BSA, is organized, that program does not use the patrol method. Instead, it uses a corporate-bureaucracy simulation, which makes it an outlier in the broader Scouting world. ↩︎
    3. Baden-Powell did not use the modern American term “high schooler”, but the age range in his 1918 proposal is analogous to today’s high-school years. ↩︎
  • High schoolers are not troop staff

    High schoolers are not troop staff

    Scouts BSA is a program for ages 10-17.1 That age span is the problem.

    The lived experience is a middle-school program that traps high schoolers, then asks them to supervise the middle schoolers. That is a babysitting program decorated with leadership language.

    High schoolers are simply unpaid staff for the middle-school program.

    Series note: This is the last part of a series on how BSA’s gold loopers stole the patrol method, replacing it with a corporate-bureaucracy simulation.

    Part 1: The patrol method is not a youth bureaucracy
    Part 2: How the troop bureaucracy acquired a leadership theory
    Part 3: How troop positions of responsibility steal patrol ownership
    Part 4: Adults must stop hiding behind youth offices

    Mixed-age patrols expose the contradiction

    The tension appears in BSA’s own troop-structure guidance, where gold loopers speak out of both sides of their mouth regarding mixed-age patrols. That is where a 10-year-old and a 17-year-old are peers in the same patrol.

    BSA’s online documentation presents mixed-age patrols favorably, falsely claiming it is the historical model2 and placing them first in a list, without qualification.3 The adult-leader guidebook praises the same model, presenting it as the historical approach that has “several advantages”.4

    But then gold loopers’ literature admits the problem: 10-year-olds and 17-year-olds have little in common.5 It offers new-Scout, regular, and older-Scout patrols as a “better approach”.6

    More broadly, this is about the program, not just the patrols. The three-tier patrol scheme is still part of a culture that traps high schoolers in the middle-school program to serve as unpaid staff.

    Gold loopers have long known that high schoolers need something different. The 1938 Guide Book of Senior Scouting admits this, calling it “one fact that we cannot escape” that a high schooler’s needs differ from those of younger youth.7

    Today, BSA is alone among its international peers, still trapping high schoolers in a middle-school program:

    The troop converts high schoolers into staff

    Many troops fill troop-level titled roles with high schoolers. Not always, but commonly enough that the pattern matters. High schoolers are routinely called out to operate the bureaucracy that keeps the middle schoolers in line. Even when placed in their own patrol, even without a titled role, high schoolers are still pulled toward troop-level instruction and supervision, especially of the youngest youth.

    That is babysitting.

    The since-abandoned Leadership Corps admits to this logic. The 1981 Scoutmaster Handbook described it as a troop structure for 14- and 15-year-old troop-level bureaucrats. The theory is that it would also allow them some activities of their own, holding their interest in Scouting while providing “leadership” services for the troop.8

    Strip away the vocabulary and the bargain is obvious: high schoolers remain in a middle-school program to provide babysitting services, with occasional chances at age-appropriate programming on the side.

    Middle schoolers and high schoolers both lose

    Middle schoolers lose first because the staffing model displaces patrol ownership. They get a program mediated through high-school instruction and crowd control, rather than one centered on their own patrols and their own developmental needs.

    High schoolers lose leadership development. Gold loopers often pretend that Scouts BSA can remain appropriate for high schoolers by giving them the corporate-bureaucracy simulation to operate. The bargain is blunt: stay in the middle-school program, hold an office, keep middle schoolers moving, and call that leadership.

    Running a bureaucracy is not leadership. Fulfilling a check-boxed role, keeping eleven-year-olds in line, delivering concrete instructions to middle schoolers, and maintaining an adult-authored organization chart do not give high schoolers leadership experience. It just makes them bureaucrats.

    Leadership is a mutual-influence process: earning trust, motivating skeptical peers, shaping a shared vision, and moving with people who can push back.

    That leadership work is messy because peers are not subordinates. Crucial to leadership development is the give-and-take of similar-age peers: skepticism, disagreement, ambition, status, humor, resistance, and buy-in.

    In cross-age interactions in a formal-supervision scheme, the age gap alone, plus how early adolescents still tend to be rather concrete and literal, create authority without before a word is even spoken. This displaces the social processes–the influence dynamic–that is table stakes to leadership. This is a supervision system, not leadership training.

    Scouts BSA withholds genuine leadership development while praising high schoolers for supervising middle schoolers inside a tidy corporate-bureaucracy simulation.

    The defenses fail

    The defenses arrive in a familiar cluster. High schoolers should “give back”. Offices supposedly keep them engaged. The troop bureaucracy supposedly needs officeholders. Troops supposedly need high schoolers for continuity and expertise. High-school staffing is supposedly inherent to Scouting.

    These claims sound practical until they are taken seriously.

    “Giving back” is not a debt

    “Giving back” as an institutional expectation seeks involuntary servitude while obscuring it with cheery language.

    Help received as a middle schooler is not a labor debt. Scouting service is voluntary and generous, not a bill that comes due when the middle schoolers enter 9th grade.

    No age band of Scouts owes anything to any other age band of Scouts.

    “Keeping them engaged” is not a program

    Gold loopers have long tried to use troop-level youth offices as a retention device.

    Their 1938 Senior Scouting guide, even while providing excellent supports for why high schoolers should be in “Senior Scouting” programs, claimed that many high-school-aged Scouts found satisfaction in filling positions of responsibility.9 The 1959 Scoutmaster’s Handbook made the same workaround explicit, saying the Junior Assistant Scoutmaster office may “hold the interest of older boys”.10

    Strip the cheery veneer and look at the blunt truth: Instead of moving high schoolers into an age-appropriate program with broader adventure and age-level peer experiences, gold loopers kept them tied to the middle-school program by handing them bureaucratic, titled roles.

    “We need officeholders” is circular

    The officeholder defense is circular. It says high schoolers must remain in Scouts BSA because the troop’s corporate-bureaucracy simulation must be staffed. This treats a need created by this bureaucracy as proof that high schoolers belong in the middle-school program.

    A better answer is to stop clinging to myths, specifically that bureaucratic roles are the program or are essential to Scouting. The best answer is to restore the patrol method, abolishing all troop-level youth-staffed offices. The patrol method is not a troop-level bureaucracy!

    “Troop continuity” is troop convenience

    The continuity defense is troop convenience dressed up as youth development.

    If meetings, campouts, and new-Scout instruction depend on high schoolers managing middle schoolers, that indicts the troop machinery. Adult leaders must handle troop-level continuity without turning high schoolers into staff, and patrols can still own their own activities.

    “Expertise transfer” does not require a staffing class

    The expertise-transfer defense has a narrow truth. A high schooler may choose to teach a skill or serve as a limited Guide (expanded below). That is voluntary service under adult guidance, not a condition of being in Scouting, not a reason to assign a whole age cohort to manage middle schoolers, not a reason to trap high schoolers in a middle-school program.

    Adults have a duty of adult association. It’s what we signed up for, a part of being a direct-contact adult leader. Part of that duty is mentoring all youth directly, not hiding behind youth offices.

    High-school staffing is not inherent to Scouting

    The claim that high-school staffing is inherent to Scouting is absurd.

    Baden-Powell did not want high schoolers trapped inside a middle-school program. After observing older youth leaving the program and noting substantial differences between older and younger youth, Baden-Powell recommended in 1918 that older youth have their own program that meets separately.11

    Per the chart near the top of this article, BSA is the last of its international peer organizations to not adopt this 1918 vision. That 90% of BSA’s high schoolers linger in its middle-school program makes BSA an outlier.

    A Guide is a compromise, not the cure

    A Guide role may have a place as a compromise. I have argued elsewhere for creating Guides as a position of responsibility. The role must be created alongside the end of the babysitting regime, not as a new name for it.

    A Guide must be voluntary, limited, adult-supervised, and available across programs: a youth, while active in an age-level program, may choose to serve a program for a younger age band.

    That is not assigning a whole class of high schoolers to staff a middle-school program. A Guide is a service opportunity. It cannot be the theory of high-school membership.

    To re-emphasize: Voluntary service is a non-negotiable aspect of the Guide role. If none of a community’s high schoolers are interested in being a Guide, then middle schoolers will exclusively receive adult mentorship. That’s fine. High-school staffing of a middle-school program is not essential to Scouting and must never be compelled.

    The age-section prescription is simple

    I have made the full age-section argument elsewhere: Scouts BSA is a middle-school program, early founders pointed toward differentiated programs, BSA’s international peers use differentiated age sections, and high schoolers belong in an age-level program.

    The program-design prescription is summarized in the Move Forward: Save Scouting proposal: Scouts BSA will focus on grades 6-8. Youth in grades 9-12, including 18-year-old seniors12, should be in Venturing or Sea Scouts. Starting with high-school graduation, Venturers and Sea Scouts graduate to Rovers13, a worldwide program that gold loopers killed in the 1950s.

    Shiny objects and older-Scout patrols are just pressure valves

    Gold loopers’ literature calls the older-Scout patrol a safety valve.14 That safety valve leaves the faulty architecture intact: a ten-year-old and a seventeen-year-old do not need the same program, pace, or adult posture.

    Gold loopers also create shiny objects that help sustain the staffing bargain: high adventure, paid camp staffing, and Order of the Arrow. The theory is these occasional escapes help keep high schoolers registered in the middle-school program.

    While OA is a shiny object today, I have argued elsewhere that it must be retired.

    High adventure and camp staffing are great. But once this occasional escape is completed, the high schooler returns to being infantilized, to babysitting duties in a troop.

    The value of high adventure and camp staffing would increase if they were adjuncts to an actual high-school program, or to Rovers for high-school graduates. As substitutes for age-appropriate program design, they are diminished.

    Admitting high-school disgust with the bargain

    High schoolers are disgusted with the bargain. “Eagling out” is the common phenomenon where high schoolers, tired of babysitting chores and being infantilized in a middle-school program, head to the exit as they complete Eagle. Another common phenomenon is quiet quitting, where a high schooler reduces involvement or disappears while remaining on the roster, resurfacing only in time to knock out Eagle before turning 18. A third common phenomenon are high schoolers who have resigned themselves to their disgust of babysitting chores, showing up but clearly conflicted about why he’s there.

    Conversations on this often turn to a “blame the unit-volunteer” ethic, a common, blame-shifting tactic of gold loopers to avoid accountability for their own incompetence.

    BSA tacitly admits to this disgust. The following passage responds to that unstated frustration15:

    You might think of Venturing and Sea Scouts as somewhat akin to the Scoutmasters’ lounge at summer camp: a place to renew and refresh before diving back into the work of leading a troop.

    Here, BSA admits that high schoolers are tired of babysitting chores, frustrated with being infantilized in a middle-school program. That is why high schoolers would need to “renew and refresh”. The troop program no longer works for them! But instead of providing age-level program that meets their needs, the prescription is only a relief valve.

    Also, this sentiment minimizes the high-school programs. Unlike Scouts BSA, they use the patrol method, and they support leadership development. Just as bullies target qualities in others they are jealous of, gold loopers representing the middle-school program snipe at the programs all high schoolers should be in.

    End the staffing bargain

    Today’s Scouts BSA program design induces a problem, then it calls management of that problem “leadership”.

    For middle schoolers, good Scouting means patrols with ownership, mentored by adults. For high schoolers, it means an actual high-school program: Venturing or Sea Scouts.

    The series ends where it began: the patrol method is not a youth bureaucracy. Restore patrol ownership, restore adult association, and move high schoolers into an age-appropriate program. The troop no longer needs high schoolers to staff a machine that should not exist.

    However, if inaction remains the gold-looper playbook, then BSA should at least have the honesty to pay the babysitters.

    Footnotes

    1. Scouts BSA: Frequently Asked Questions, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    2. In the context of an ages 10-17 program–an 8 year age span–it is disingenuous to claim that mixed-age patrols are the historical approach, especially without qualification. In his 1908 Scouting for Boys, Scouting’s founder Robert Baden-Powell recommended same-age patrols. BSA’s own 1913 manual for Scoutmasters warned that the presence of younger youth can “drive out” the older youth. In 1918, after having gained considerable experience following his 1907 Brownsea Island experiment, Baden-Powell recommended older youth be moved to their own program. Since then, all of BSA’s international peer Scouting organizations–UK, Australia, Mexico, Canada, Ireland, and many more–have fulfilled the founder’s vision. Generally, all their programs span only 3-4 years. Due to its intransigence on this, BSA is an outlier on the world stage. 3-4 year age spans map to common understandings of adolescent developmental stages. 8-year age spans combine considerably different developmental stages, an entirely different proposition. Cast more accurately, it is absurd to claim that mixed-age patrols in a program that spans 8 years is the historical approach. Rather, it is the approach of an organization beset by inertia and indifferent about the quality, effectiveness, and safety of the programs it designed. ↩︎
    3. Types of Patrols, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America ↩︎
    4. Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, p. 17. ↩︎
    5. Ibid., pp. 64-65. ↩︎
    6. Ibid., pp. 17-18. ↩︎
    7. Guide Book of Senior Scouting, Boy Scouts of America, 1938, p. 6. ↩︎
    8. Scoutmaster Handbook, Boy Scouts of America, 1981, pp. 63-65. ↩︎
    9. Boy Scouts of America, Guide Book of Senior Scouting, 1938, pp. 15-17. Note: This claim holds no water. Despite decades of this experiment—retaining high schoolers while trapping them in a middle-school program—no evidence exists that it has meaningfully improved older-youth retention. ↩︎
    10. Boy Scouts of America, Scoutmaster’s Handbook, Fifth Edition, 1959, p 53. ↩︎
    11. Provisional Rules for Rover-Scouts, 6th Edition, The Boy Scouts Association (UK), Sept. 1918, p. 5. ↩︎
    12. Current youth-protection standards must be changed to accommodate societal norms. 18-year-old high-school seniors must be treated the same as other high schoolers. For example, if an 18-year-old 12th grader wishes to buddy with a 16-year-old 11th-grade friend, that must not be prohibited. ↩︎
    13. Rovers is a young-adult program. Mapped to USA norms, Rovers would begin at high-school graduation. ↩︎
    14. Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, p. 17. ↩︎
    15. Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 2, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, p. 124. ↩︎
  • Adults must stop hiding behind youth offices

    Adults must stop hiding behind youth offices

    The Scouts BSA corporate-bureaucracy simulation displaced patrol ownership and gave adults a place to hide.

    The phrase “Ask your SPL” is one symptom. In the culture of the middle-school program (Scouts BSA), it often means an adult has declined to mentor a child, instead routing the Scout into the youth-staffed, troop-office bureaucracy. Adult abdication gets dressed up as youth-led practice, then openly celebrated:

    Example of a troop reflecting a culture of rejecting the adult-association method of Scouting. (Source intentionally withheld.)

    The adult-association method is core to Scouting. Adults cannot fulfill that method by withholding it. They must know Scouts and patrols directly.

    Series note: This is part 4 of a five-part series on how BSA’s gold loopers stole the patrol method, replacing it with a corporate-bureaucracy simulation.

    Part 1: The patrol method is not a youth bureaucracy
    Part 2: How the troop bureaucracy acquired a leadership theory
    Part 3: How troop positions of responsibility steal patrol ownership
    Part 5: High schoolers are not troop staff

    Adult association is not optional

    Adult association must comply with BSA’s youth-safeguarding standards.1 Especially important is the “no one-on-one contact” rule, which must always be upheld.

    “Association with Adults” is one of the methods of Scouts BSA. Youth learn by watching adult conduct and by having adult leaders who listen, encourage, and “take a sincere interest in them”.2

    The current adult-leader guidebook contains adult-association language: adults should listen, encourage, challenge, guide, make themselves available on hikes and campouts, provide quiet support during patrol work, and strengthen mentoring relationships on outings.3

    The trouble is the competing instruction. Through the same guidebook, gold loopers normalize a Scoutmaster “reced[ing] into the background” as the Senior Patrol Leader becomes “more effective”.4 In practice, that becomes a culture where adults hide behind troop-level youth offices and call their distance youth leadership.

    Adult association is not a decoration added after “youth-led” has supposedly done the real work. It is core to how Scouting develops youth.

    The danger used to be stated more plainly. The 1922 Handbook for Scoutmasters warned that when Scoutmasters lose personal touch with the youth, that may lead to military discipline and classroom methods. By 1981, the Scoutmaster Handbook still recognized that Scoutmaster conferences could build adult-Scout relationships, but it placed that relationship-building inside scheduled set-pieces. The old warning was about losing personal touch. The later structure made personal touch easier to isolate from ordinary troop life.5

    As the corporate-bureaucracy simulation swallowed the Scouts BSA program, administration became the dominant concern, and adult association became easier to confine to scheduled moments while the daily life of the troop was routed through youth-staffed bureaucratic offices.

    Association is relational, and administration is structural. This series opposes the second and pleads for the first.

    Baden-Powell prescribed adult presence

    Baden-Powell’s language was relational. BSA’s own curation of Baden-Powell quotations includes the idea that the Scoutmaster guides the boy in the spirit of an “older brother” and knows the boys well enough to understand them.6 This phrasing matters because of the posture behind it: adults close enough to know youth and guide them without taking over.

    Elsewhere, Baden-Powell described Scouting as “a game for boys … in which elder brothers can give their younger brothers a healthy environment and encourage them to healthy activities such as will help them to develop.”7 By “elder brother”, Baden-Powell was referring to adults, not high-school substitutes.

    Baden-Powell was describing adults close enough to know the youth, restrained enough not to commandeer their work, and mature enough to translate adult judgment into the language of youth. That posture leaves no room for adults standing at the back of the room while a high-school bureaucrat relays every meaningful interaction.

    “Ask your SPL” is adult absence

    In gold loopers’ corporate-bureaucracy simulation, “Ask your SPL” is the polite version of adult abdication.

    A Scout confused about a Tenderfoot rank requirement should not be bounced through a teen chain of command. A homesick Scout should not be told to find the right youth manager. A patrol chef should not be unsupported when cooking the pancakes. A Patrol Leader who is overwhelmed should not be treated as if the only adult relationship available is a scheduled meeting with the Scoutmaster after the PLC. Yet that is the culture encouraged by the “Ask your SPL” retort.

    The 1981 Scoutmaster Handbook made that posture sound normal. Its model of a good troop has the Scoutmaster away from the meeting while youth in bureaucratic roles run the operations: the Senior Patrol Leader runs the meeting, the Scribe keeps records, the Patrol Leaders’ Council plans, and Patrol Leaders keep order.8

    Example of merchandise reflecting a culture of rejecting the adult-association method of Scouting. (Image credit: PATCHTOWN)

    The 1981 adult-leader handbook tells the Scoutmaster to work into the background and put the youth-staffed troop-office machinery into the foreground.9 The current adult-leader guidebook is mixed. It preserves some good adult-association language, but still puts adults inside a structure where youth bureaucrats—the SPL, Assistant SPL, youth offices, and PLC—carry the operating load.10 The result is not youth initiative, and it’s not leadership. It’s just youth operating a machine while adults admire their own absence.

    Adults should know patrols directly

    Another example of competing instruction in the adult-leader guidebook is how adults are encouraged to focus direct mentorship to the youth-office structure.11 If they do this, ordinary Scouts lose much direct adult association, Patrol Leaders are undermined as patrols lose adult focus, and the bureaucracy gains false moral authority. The previous article explains how unit adults inherited that self-reproducing machine.

    Adults need a direct feel for patrol life: what each patrol is attempting, which Scouts are growing, which Scouts are isolated, which Patrol Leaders are earning trust, and which conflicts are ordinary friction rather than real harm.

    Adults therefore have to tolerate some disorder. A patrol sorting through disagreement is not automatically a management failure. It may be the exact place where leadership is being learned. The adult task is to keep that space safe, humane, and developmental. That does not happen when the adult replaces association with a corporate-bureaucracy simulation, even though that bureaucracy looks cleaner from across the room.

    Adults should mentor Patrol Leaders without converting them into middle managers. They should help a Patrol Leader ask better questions: What does your patrol want? Who is quiet? What are you worried about? What can you try before an adult steps in? What did you learn from the last failure?

    Teen staff are not adult association

    Cross-age help among youth can have value in narrow circumstances (see next section), that does not substitute for adults knowing and mentoring middle schoolers directly.

    In the troop-office chain, high schoolers often become the adults’ front line: supervisors, instructors, and buffers between adults and middle schoolers.12 That turns teen help into a babysitting regime with leadership language painted on it.

    The substitution damages both age groups. Middle schoolers lose the adult relationships that are core to Scouting. High schoolers lose the chance to pursue age-level adventure with peers because they are kept in the middle-school program as staff. The adult-association failure starts here: adults have handed off a method of Scouting to youth offices.

    Middle schoolers especially need this distinction. Research on adolescent support notes that younger adolescents may report more support from parents and other adults compared to older adolescents.13 BSA has every reason to preserve intentional, non-parental adult association in Scouts BSA, a program whose developmental focus is middle school.

    Cross-age mentoring must be adult-guided…

    The cross-age mentoring research supports a narrow proposition: older youth can help middle schoolers when adults build and supervise the relationship. A meta-analysis of cross-age mentoring found positive effects, but the stronger programs had moderate or high adult oversight and supervision. That finding supports adult-guided help from older youth, not teen substitution.14

    The comparison evidence is cautionary. In a review of Big Brothers Big Sisters school-based mentoring, high-school mentors supported by local BBBS agencies did not significantly improve many school-related measures compared with non-mentored youth. The broader BBBS comparison likewise found some relational advantages for older-peer mentoring, but weaker or absent results on misconduct, classroom effort, and academic competence. Adult mentoring may not win every comparison, but the research does not justify turning middle schoolers over to high schoolers.15

    The program-design literature points the same direction. In this research, “peer” does not mean that a 17-year-old is an ordinary program peer of a 10-year-old. It means an older or more-experienced youth in a defined helping role with someone younger or less experienced. That role needs clear objectives, matching, training, monitoring, guidance, and evaluation. The National Mentoring Resource Center likewise treats cross-age mentoring as promising but only preliminarily backed by evidence, and it stresses adult guidance, training, and supervision.16

    That structured mentoring model is different from ordinary Scouts BSA culture, where high schoolers are expected to manage middle schoolers as part of the troop machine, all the while pretending to be program peers to the middle schoolers, in an environment where adults are encouraged to keep their distance. The research can support approachable, adult-guided help from older youth. It does not validate BSA’s jumbled program design, where high schoolers are trapped in a program designed around the developmental stage of middle schoolers.

    …but adult mentoring is good

    The adult-mentoring evidence supplies the positive case for adult association. A meta-analysis associated natural adult mentoring with positive youth outcomes, especially when the relationship itself was high quality.17 A large meta-analysis of intergenerational youth mentoring programs likewise found statistically significant effects across youth outcomes.18 Other research on youth support systems describes supportive youth-adult relationships as sources of care, challenge, support, expanded possibility, and shared power.19

    That evidence fits the ordinary advantages of adult maturity. Adults bring judgment, accountability, emotional range, and distance from the peer-status games that shape adolescence. That maturity lets them teach, protect, and interpret without asking high schoolers to impersonate adults.

    Adult association fits the evidence. A troop culture built on teen substitution lacks that support.

    The repair is active adult association

    The repair is simple but not passive: adults in Scouts BSA should be close enough to know Scouts and restrained enough to let patrols own their work.

    Adults can ask questions, teach skills, notice risk, and speak directly with Scouts without turning every problem into adult control. That is healthy adult partnership: direct, accountable, and respectful of patrol ownership.

    What does that look like in practice? It looks ordinary, and it stays inside Scouting’s safeguards.

    On a campout, an adult moves through the patrol sites and stops where a patrol is cooking. The adult asks how the meal is coming, watches a new Scout fumble the stove, and shows the fix directly rather than waiting for the SPL to be summoned. The adult notices a Scout sitting apart from the group and finds a reason to bring them back in. None of that requires a title, a scheduled meeting, or involvement of a troop-level youth bureaucrat.

    A Scoutmaster conference unrelated to advancement is another channel, and it works when it is a conversation rather than a checklist, when it results in adult action and support instead of passive listening then forgetting. It may include asking what a Scout is enjoying, what is hard, and who they are becoming.

    Sometimes direct association means visibly doing nothing: an adult watches a patrol argue its way through a bad plan, stays close enough to intervene if anyone is at risk, and lets the patrol own the outcome. Presence is not control. The adult who can stand near a struggling patrol without seizing the wheel is practicing adult association in its hardest form.

    In each scene the adult is close, accountable, and visible, and in no scene is the patrol’s self-ownership challenged. The safeguards that govern adult-youth contact never required adult distance—only that adult presence be conducted in the open. Distance was never the rule. It became the habit years before safeguarding was even a thing in BSA.

    Restoring adult association weakens the Scouts BSA troop-office machinery because that structure depends on adult distance. Once adults resume direct mentorship, troop-level youth-bureaucrat offices lose their borrowed moral authority.

    Scouts BSA’s repair

    A repaired Scouts BSA program would set aside the gold loopers’ corporate-bureaucracy simulation. It would be rebuilt around patrol ownership. Adults would be present. Youth would own real adventures. No high schooler would be asked to substitute for the adults Scouting promised would be there.

    The next article follows the cost of that substitution for high schoolers themselves: deprived of age-level programming, most are trapped inside a middle-school program, then praised for operating the very bureaucracy that traps them there.

    Footnotes

    1. Scouting’s Barriers to Abuse, Scouting America. ↩︎
    2. Scouts BSA: The Aims and Methods of Scouting, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    3. Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, pp. 15, 70, 127, 130. ↩︎
    4. Ibid., PDF p. 20. ↩︎
    5. Handbook for Scoutmasters, Second Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1922, p. 16;The Official Scoutmaster Handbook, Seventh Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1981, pp. 147-149. ↩︎
    6. Pearls of Wisdom – Quotes from Baden-Powell, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    7. Robert Baden-Powell, Aids to Scoutmastership, 1944, p. 6. The elder-brother framing appears elsewhere in the book as well. ↩︎
    8. The Official Scoutmaster Handbook, Seventh Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1981, p. 19. ↩︎
    9. Ibid., pp. 18-22. ↩︎
    10. Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, pp. 85-88, 127. ↩︎
    11. Ibid., pp. 11, 69-72, 83-84. ↩︎
    12. For a BSA-hosted example of the chain-of-command posture, see Kip Krumwiede, “Lessons I Learned as a Scout Leader,” Boy Scouts of America, 2020, especially the section “Respecting the Chain of Command.” ↩︎
    13. Caroline L. Bokhorst, Sindy R. Sumpter, and P. Michiel Westenberg, “Social Support from Parents, Friends, Classmates, and Teachers in Children and Adolescents Aged 9 to 18 Years: Who Is Perceived as Most Supportive?”, Social Development, 2010. This is cited by and expanded on in Shannon M. Varga, Mark Vincent B. Yu, Haley E. Johnson, Valerie Futch Ehrlich, and Nancy L. Deutsch, “‘It’s going to help me in life‘: Forms, sources, and functions of social support for youth in natural mentoring relationships”, Journal of Community Psychology, 2023. ↩︎
    14. Samantha Burton, Elizabeth B. Raposa, Cyanea Y. S. Poon, Geert Jan J. M. Stams, and Jean Rhodes, Cross-age peer mentoring for youth: A meta-analysis, American Journal of Community Psychology 70 (2022): 211-227, PDF pp. 1-3, 9, 11. ↩︎
    15. Burton et al., Cross-age peer mentoring for youth: A meta-analysis, PDF pp. 2, 5. ↩︎
    16. Michael J. Karcher and Joshua R. M. Berger, One-to-One Cross-Age Peer Mentoring: National Mentoring Resource Center Model Review, National Mentoring Resource Center, September 2017; Linlin Luo and Heidrun Stoeger, Unlocking the transformative power of mentoring for youth development in communities, schools, and talent domains, Journal of Community Psychology 51 (2023): 3067-3082, PDF pp. 2, 7-10. ↩︎
    17. L. Van Dam, D. Smit, B. Wildschut, S. Branje, J. Rhodes, M. Assink, and G. Stams, Does Natural Mentoring Matter? A Multilevel Meta-analysis on the Association Between Natural Mentoring and Youth Outcomes, American Journal of Community Psychology, 2018. ↩︎
    18. Elizabeth B. Raposa et al., The Effects of Youth Mentoring Programs: A Meta-analysis of Outcome Studies, Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 2019. ↩︎
    19. Taylor N. Melton, Maya V. Brehm, and Nancy L. Deutsch, Broadening the perspective on youth’s systems of support: An ecological examination of supportive peer and adult relationships during adolescence, Journal of Community Psychology, 2021. ↩︎
  • How troop positions of responsibility steal patrol ownership

    How troop positions of responsibility steal patrol ownership

    Troop-level positions of responsibility undermine the patrol method. They steal ownership from patrols by taking over decisions that should belong to small teams, and they teach Scouts that real responsibility sits outside the patrol.

    Even the thin positions matter. They pull youth away from patrol programs and into troop-level duties that are often just make-work.

    The roster changes where everyone looks for responsibility. Patrols lose autonomy when Scouts treat troop-level titles as the owners of concerns. This reduces the patrol to a labor pool for someone else’s plan, or a side project beneath the troop machine.

    Gold loopers legitimize the swap by calling it leadership. That word hides a youth-staffed bureaucracy.

    The first article in this series argued that gold loopers replaced patrol ownership with a youth-operated corporate-bureaucracy simulation. The second article traced how gold loopers built this simulation and gave it a leadership-development theory. This article looks inside the machinery: troop offices and advancement incentives that deflate the patrol method.

    Series note: This is part three of a five-part series on how BSA’s gold loopers stole the patrol method, replacing it with a corporate-bureaucracy simulation. (The next articles will be published in a few days.)

    Part 1: The patrol method is not a youth bureaucracy
    Part 2: How the troop bureaucracy acquired a leadership theory
    Part 4: Adults must stop hiding behind youth offices
    Part 5: High schoolers are not troop staff

    Troop offices pre-decide patrol work

    Start with the main patrol-method question: “How will this patrol own its adventure?”

    Troop positions of responsibility often answer that question before the patrol can ask it. Every formal troop-level office above the patrol is a decision already made, an opportunity thieved from the patrol.

    A troop needs troop-level coordination. The first article put that work where it belongs: a congress of patrol leaders whose authority rises from the patrols.

    Over the 20th century, gold loopers neutered patrols, moving authority from patrols to a corporate-bureaucracy simulation. This simulation became the troop operating model. The simulation was institutionalized in the 1972 Improved Scouting Program.

    The 1981 Official Scoutmaster Handbook illustrated this simulation, describing troop-level bureaucratic positions as “natural”, naming the Senior Patrol Leader as the “big shot” who “directs Patrol Leaders, chairs the Patrol Leaders’ Council, and is in charge of the troop”, then treating other roles, like Quartermaster, Scribe, and more, as obvious troop-level answers whenever a related concern arises.1 Before the patrol could ask how to solve a problem, gold loopers had already bureaucratized the answer.

    Troop organization chart, as specified by The Official Scoutmaster Handbook, 1981. It shows how decisions that would normally have been up to patrols became bureaucratized and moved to troop-level roles.2

    The organization chart takes sides. It tells adults and Scouts that the troop’s real operating logic is bureaucracy, not leadership, with ownership centered in troop offices instead of patrols.

    The thefts are different

    The corporate-bureaucracy simulation damages patrol ownership by changing who sets the program, where decisions are made, where Scouts look for direction, who participates in patrol life, how patrols learn, who provides adult association, and what receives status.

    The Senior Patrol Leader role and Patrol Leaders’ Council apparatus pull program ownership out of patrols. Instructor and Troop Guide shift patrol learning into troop-level youth offices, displacing adult association. Other roles, like Quartermaster, Scribe, and Historian, are softer examples, but they still show patrol concerns yielding to bureaucratic youth titles on a troop roster.

    This heavy administrative machinery was not part of Baden-Powell’s design for Scouting. Even early administrative youth roles in BSA, like Scribe, began emerging in the 1910s to help with the paperwork and logistical burdens of growing units. They were practical answers to administrative problems, not proof that patrol ownership had to give way to a youth-staffed office chart.

    In other national programs, the framing tends to be healthier. Where analogues to BSA’s bureaucratic youth offices even exist, these are typically informal roles that are subordinate to patrol life, rotated among patrol members, and used to strengthen the patrol. They generally don’t build a troop-level bureaucracy that displaces patrol ownership. For example, Scouts Ireland describes analogous roles as “roles within the Patrol” that “reinforce a Scout’s sense of belonging to a Patrol”.3

    World Scouting frames the same principle structurally rather than anecdotally. Its team system is “not a pyramidal structure for the transmission of orders”.4 Instead, each small team provides its own leadership and “the young people organise their life as a group.”5 National programs follow suit. The Scout Association in the United Kingdom centers its youth structure on Patrol Leaders rather than a roster of troop offices, and treats the Patrol Leaders’ Council not as a governing body but as a way “to make sure that the adult leadership team hears from young people.”6 Scouts Australia, under a “Youth Leading, Adults Supporting” model, locates leadership in the patrol: “the role of the Patrol Leader is to lead their patrol”. Patrols rotate responsibility for troop-level activities, coordinated through an informal council of Patrol Leaders.7

    Worldwide norm for the patrol method is on left, where troops consist of patrols with no troop-level youth bureaucracy. The Patrol Leaders manage troop-level concerns in congress, with advice and counsel of the Scoutmaster. The right side, which resembles the common experience of BSA’s corporate-bureaucracy simulation, is the structure this article series exists to criticize. Source: Scouting: An Educational System, World Organization of the Scout Movement, p. 26.

    Program determination moves upstairs

    Every troop office is a stored decision, a governance choice pre-encoded before the patrol can make it.

    The biggest stored decision is program ownership. The Senior Patrol Leader description makes the point plainly: the SPL chairs troop meetings, events, activities, the annual program planning conference, and Patrol Leaders’ Council meetings, while also appointing other troop youth leaders and assigning duties.8 But the stored decision is not just one youth title. It is the apparatus itself: troop program is made upstairs, and Patrol Leaders are trained to feed input into that machinery rather than lead independent patrol programs.

    When answers sit in troop-level offices, troop-level action becomes the program, upending the patrol method. BSA affirms the primacy of troop-level programming: “[m]ost patrol activities take place in the context of troop activities” and may not “conflict with the troop calendar”.9

    Patrols may still divide chores inside a troop event, but chores are not ownership. A patrol can decide who brings the stove yet have little meaningful say over its program.

    The Patrol Leaders’ Council name misleads. It sounds like a congress of patrols. In fact, it is the “troop’s elected and duly appointed governing body”, a standing bureaucratic committee chaired by the SPL.10 A key part of the corporate-bureaucracy simulation, this committee reduces Patrol Leaders to middle management inside a troop machine. The patrol is still visible, but ownership of its destiny has been moved upstairs. The adult-leader guidebook reinforces the supremacy of troop-level planning, with Patrol Leaders not being pulled into annual event planning until the Scoutmaster and SPL have already drafted a plan.11

    Removal of officers from patrols

    Presumably to allow sufficient focus to operate the Scouts BSA bureaucratic machine, the SPL, Assistant SPL, and Troop Guide are not members of patrols.12 This is not just a distraction from patrol life. The corporate-bureaucracy simulation removes them from the patrol method.

    Adult leaders have long debated how the SPL should relate to ordinary patrols because an SPL can overshadow the Patrol Leader of whichever patrol he joins. That gives away the problem. The office is treated as powerful enough that adults must manage its effect on ordinary patrol operations.13

    Troop offices steal patrol-based learning and adult association

    A patrol that owns its adventure also owns much of its learning. If its members cannot cook, tie a knot, or care for a new member, the problem belongs to the patrol. That isn’t always orderly, yet that is where patrol leadership starts.

    In the patrol method, adult association is the backstop. Adults stand in relationship with patrols and mentor them toward greater capability.

    The corporate-bureaucracy simulation pushes troop-level Instructor and Troop Guide roles into the space where patrol learning and adult association should happen.

    BSA’s Instructor description assigns basic-Scout-skill instruction and merit-badge-counselor coordination to this youth bureaucrat.14 The Troop Guide partly overlaps Instructor, partly provides specialized training for Patrol Leaders.15 Neither of these roles comes close to the mentoring relationship of a caring adult.

    Even with good intentions, the younger patrol’s leader becomes a person being managed rather than the person leading. Growth and team formation both suffer.16

    Patrols should not be left ignorant. Adults should help them develop the habit of teaching, orienting, and strengthening themselves. The theft happens when the patrol learns to receive instruction from the troop’s youth bureaucracy instead of owning that development with appropriate adult partnership.

    The roster makes patrols look upward

    A youth troop office pulls bureaucracy into the youth program. It gives one youth a title over a concern that might otherwise belong to patrols, adults, or nobody at all. Scouts then spend less time influencing peers inside a patrol and more time staffing an adult-authored roster of bureaucratic offices. Patrol autonomy disappears by habit. Everyone keeps looking upward.

    Quartermaster, Scribe, and Historian show the pattern. The Quartermaster is assigned records on patrol and troop equipment, equipment issuing, and related administrative chores.17 The Scribe is described as the troop’s secretary, attending PLC meetings, recording discussions, coordinating attendance, and maintaining advancement records.18 The Historian gathers photos and facts about troop activities, cares for troop trophies and souvenirs, and keeps information about former troop members.19

    These offices steal differently. Gear has a real patrol dimension. Records may be necessary but mostly serve troop administration. Historian is a thin role that often exposes make-work. Together, they show how the troop-office roster changes the center of gravity. A patrol should care for its own gear habits, decide what records help its own members, and choose whether it wishes to memorialize its own adventures. The troop office teaches a different lesson: look outside the patrol for the real owner.

    Scouters sometimes ask how to make these bureaucratic offices meaningful when the natural work is thin. The answers often become make-work: newsletters, spreadsheets, social media, attendance logs, binders, kits, closets, photo rosters, and reminders. Some of that work may have a patina of value. But this is bureaucracy. Calling it youth leadership shows how far the office roster has wandered from leadership or the patrol method.20

    A theme of the youth-staffed, troop-level bureaucratic roles is how they take on troop-level responsibilities that adults should handle in the background. Adults can track shared equipment, keep a website updated, add to a troop scrapbook, and check attendance. That is just administrative work, not leadership. It should not compete with the Patrol Leader’s authority, remove a patrol decision, displace Scouts from patrol involvement, or tell Scouts that the real action is in a youth-staffed bureaucracy.

    Advancement turns offices into currency

    Advancement is part of Scouting. World Scouting includes personal progression as part of the Scout Method21, and peer organizations have awards and progression. For example, The Scout Association in the United Kingdom offers badges that Scouts can work toward22, and Scouts Australia describes its Achievement Pathways as a personal progression framework that recognizes personal development23.

    Scouts BSA’s badge ladder turns troop offices into rank-advancement currency. The Star rank requires a Scout to serve four months in one or more listed positions of responsibility, or to carry out a Scoutmaster-approved “leadership project”. The Life rank does the same while raising the bar to six months. The Eagle Scout rank then eliminates the leadership-project option.24 The adult-leader guidebook makes the pressure explicit, pushing adult leaders to ensure offices are filled to support advancement.

    This guidebook even warns that receiving a badge of office does not itself make a Scout a leader. That warning is right, but the advancement machinery provides different incentives.25

    The patch becomes proof of tenure, and the Scoutmaster becomes the adult who must keep enough recognized offices available for the advancement machine.

    Motivation to advance can be healthy. But with the immense cultural weight on BSA’s advancement, the credential needs to mean more. The badge should recognize real leadership, real adventure, and real growth, not tenure in an adult-authored, bureaucratic office.

    Adventure and the patrol method have no need for a youth-staffed, troop-level Librarian role.26 The advancement system does.

    Unit adults become innocent accomplices

    Gold loopers call their troop organization chart “samples”, and technically they are. But the troop-structure page tells the Scoutmaster and Senior Patrol Leader to determine what positions the troop needs from that chart. Then it ties those positions to advancement and says all youth should have the opportunity to serve in them.27

    Adults receive the chart as ordinary Scouting, then are told advancement depends on it. This is immense pressure to conform.

    Unit-level adults are largely innocent, not understanding they were hoodwinked by gold loopers in the theft of patrol ownership. Unit-level leaders faithfully set up the very bureaucracy that displaced the patrol method: the patrol still gets a name, but the troop-position roster stripped the power and stripped adult partnership.

    The machine is easier to preserve than patrol space

    The patrol method leaves green space for personal growth. Bureaucracy paves over it.

    That green space is where leadership development happens. A patrol that owns its own program works through ambition, uncertainty, and risk. It burns pancakes, forgets tent stakes, changes its mind, argues, recovers, and discovers that a patch does not make a leader. Peer trust does, and peers can ignore you if you have not earned it.

    Gold loopers created a system with its own institutional interests: huge books, patches, advancement, training syllabi, and committees that defend their machinery. The patrol method, by contrast, asks adults to tolerate the messiness of patrol ownership.

    Gold loopers are bureaucrats. While their corporate-bureaucracy simulation is orders of magnitude more complex than the patrol method, it is also more definable. It is easier for bureaucrats to standardize and defend, plus it generates ample make-work to justify even more gold-looper volunteer and professional roles. Once gold loopers built their complex machine, their incentive was to preserve it and blame unit volunteers for failures.

    The next article turns from the youth offices to the adults standing behind them. Once adults believe that meaningful guidance must be routed through a troop-level org chart, they abandon one of Scouting’s core methods. By hiding behind this manufactured youth bureaucracy, adults sever direct mentorship of the patrol and abdicate their main duty, the adult-association method of Scouting.

    Footnotes

    1. The Official Scoutmaster Handbook, Seventh Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1981, pp. 49-54. ↩︎
    2. Ibid., p. 49. ↩︎
    3. The Scouters Manual, Scouts Ireland, 2010, p. 51. ↩︎
    4. Scouting: An Educational System, World Organization of the Scout Movement, 1998, p. 26. ↩︎
    5. The Scout Method, World Organization of the Scout Movement. ↩︎
    6. Run a Patrol Leaders’ Council, The Scout Association (UK). ↩︎
    7. Scouts Australia Official Program Resource, Patrol Leader role description (Aug 2021, v1.2); New Program Overview, Scouts Australia. ↩︎
    8. Senior Patrol Leader and Patrol Leader, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America; Scouts BSA Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, pp. 75-76. ↩︎
    9. Scouts BSA Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, p. 20. ↩︎
    10. Patrol Leader’s (sic) Council Monthly Planning, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    11. Scouts BSA Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, pp. 33-37, 119-121. ↩︎
    12. Senior Patrol Leader Handbook, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, pp. 15, 140-141. ↩︎
    13. Ibid.; also as illustrative examples: With whom does the SPL eat?, Scouter.com, April 9, 2010, and SPL and ASPL do they belong to a Patrol?, Scouter.com, September 26, 2005. ↩︎
    14. Instructor,Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    15. Troop Guide, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    16. (these are provided as illustrative examples, so this is not an exhaustive list; the depth of the argument is in the comments, sometimes not apparent by the thread titles indicated by the link names) Question About Troop Guide Position, Reddit r/BSA; using troop guides, Scouter.com; Why were Venture patrols done away with?, Scouter.com; Troop Guide in Mixed Age Patrols Without New Scout Patrol, Scouter.com; New Scout Patrol, Scouter.com; Question – Does your troop have a leadership patrol?, Reddit r/BSA. ↩︎
    17. Quartermaster, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America; Scouts BSA Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, pp. 73, 128-129. ↩︎
    18. Scribe, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America; Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, 2018, p. 73. ↩︎
    19. Historian, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America; Scouts BSA Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, p. 73. ↩︎
    20. (this is provided as an illustrative example) Making Positions of Responsibility Meaningful, Reddit r/BSA. ↩︎
    21. World Scout Youth Programme Policy and AIS, World Organization of the Scout Movement. ↩︎
    22. Scout Awards, The Scout Association. ↩︎
    23. Achievement Pathways, Scouts Australia Official Program Resource. ↩︎
    24. 2025 Scouts BSA Requirements, Boy Scouts of America, 2025, pp. 17-22. ↩︎
    25. Scouts BSA Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, pp. 16, 19, 69, 96. ↩︎
    26. Librarian, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    27. Troop Structure, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America;Scouts BSA Troop Leader Guidebook, Volume 1, Boy Scouts of America, 2018, pp. 14-15, 133. ↩︎
  • How the troop bureaucracy acquired a leadership theory

    How the troop bureaucracy acquired a leadership theory

    The Scouts BSA corporate-bureaucracy simulation did not appear all at once. Gold loopers did this gradually. They built up the troop-office machinery, wired it into advancement, and then gave that machinery a faux leadership-development theory. In 1972, gold loopers used the Improved Scouting Program to validate their gradual creep and give it a curriculum.

    The first article explained that the patrol method means self-governing patrols, not youth administration of a troop machine. This article presents the institutional history, how BSA’s gold loopers gradually stole the patrol method from our youth.

    Series note: This is part two of a five-part series on how BSA’s gold loopers stole the patrol method, replacing it with a corporate-bureaucracy simulation. (The next articles will be published in a few days.)

    Part 1: The patrol method is not a youth bureaucracy
    Part 3: How troop positions of responsibility steal patrol ownership
    Part 4: Adults must stop hiding behind youth offices
    Part 5: High schoolers are not troop staff

    The theft was gradual

    Unit-level adults did not create the corporate-bureaucracy simulation. They inherited it from from gold loopers.

    Gold loopers did not commit a single midnight theft. The records show no single heist. Instead, we see accretion, one handbook at a time.

    A troop practicing the patrol method would feel like a collection of patrols, each mentored by adults, with a focus on the patrol agendas. Over the 20th century, gold loopers gradually imposed a troop-level office layer that grew in size and prominence. That shifted the Scouts BSA program’s focus away from patrols and toward a troop-level machine. It also pulled everyday adult association back from most youth, except for those in selected, troop-level offices.

    The handbooks show patrols giving way to offices

    The Scoutmaster handbooks show the original center of gravity and the building tension. Youth-facing books repeated the same machinery.

    The 1914 Handbook for Scout Masters, First Edition, does not yet present a durable troop-office layer as the normal center of Scout operations. Its early troop-organization material is sparse: Patrol Leaders and the Scout Scribe are the only visible youth structure.1

    While the Scout Scribe was a troop-level role, it was not a functionary in youth bureaucracy. Rather, the role was practical, to assist the Scoutmaster2:

    Troop records giving details of the progress of the boys enrolled are invaluable to the Local and National Organizations. A complete set of records should therefore be kept by every troop. Inasmuch as the Scout Master himself may not be able to give the time required in the preparation of data of this kind, it is important that one of the members of the troop be chosen as Scout Scribe or Troop Secretary.

    Description of the Scout Scribe role from the 1914 Handbook for Scout Masters. This youth role provided clerical support to the Scoutmaster. It was not an officer in a youth chain of command.

    Even in 1914, though, the first seed of troop-level youth authority is visible. In one ceremony, “[i]n case there is no Assistant
    Scout Master”, a senior patrol leader (SPL) handles some ceremonial details.3 Elsewhere, the book says the senior patrol leader usually presides at troop meetings, and a model troop constitution calls the Senior Patrol Leader the Troop Leader or Troop President, with general supervision over the troop and subordinate officers. The patrol-leader-training chapter then pulls the title back toward patrol merit. It describes the SPL as a situational role filled by the “advanced or senior Patrol Leader”, or more precisely “the Leader of the patrol doing the best work”. This is not a permanent, bureaucratic supervisor position. Instead, the SPL “should occasionally be in full charge” when the troop is assembled.4

    That is the first tension: a patrol-derived honor and occasional troop function already carrying the seed of later troop-office authority. Had this been the limit of the progression, then we could comfortably say that the patrol method was still in use. But that seed later germinates.

    The 1922 Handbook for Scoutmasters, Second Edition, illustrates the patrol method5:

    In the chart, the Patrol Leader answers to no other youth and is mentored directly by the Scoutmaster. But the text grows the 1914 tension by assigning a more expansive role to the senior patrol leader6:

    Senior Patrol Leader: Preside at meetings. Lead games. Carry out plans of the Scoutmaster. Supervise and direct work of Patrol Leaders and Scouts.

    Role description from the 1922 Handbook for Scoutmasters.

    This is still not a supervisor of an expansive youth bureaucracy, and use of lower case in other sections suggests it’s still an informal role. But the word “supervise” matters. By 1922, the troop-supervisory idea is no longer theoretical. It appears in a practical division-of-labor section.

    The 1922 Handbook for Scoutmasters also lays out other troop-level administrative roles for youth. The formally recognized roles were only “Bugler and Scout Scribe”.7 But by also listing not-formally-recognized roles that were “often added” by troops, gold loopers make an early admission of a drift away from a patrol focus: “Assistant Treasurer, Librarian, Quartermaster (in charge of troop property), Scout Assistant Instructors (experienced Scouts who help the younger members), Hike Master, Drill Master, Color Bearer, Game Leader, etc.”8

    The third edition of Handbook for Scoutmasters, first published in 1936, makes the tension more visible. It still gives an entire part to “THE PATROLS IN THE TROOP,” including chapters on the patrol method, Patrol Leaders, the Troop Leaders’ Council (the body later known as the Patrol Leaders’ Council or PLC), and the working of the patrol method. Written by William Hillcourt (the famous Green Bar Bill), this text asserts the patrol method: real patrols, real Patrol Leaders, patrol meetings without adults (no longer permitted9; the point here is the handbook’s focus on the patrol program), patrol hikes, patrol projects, patrol spirit, and boy responsibility.

    Compared with 1922, the 1936 edition gives the existing pieces a fuller operating system. The 1922 edition had already named some troop jobs. The change in 1936 was structure: a detailed Troop Leaders’ Council, Green Bar Patrol, formal Junior Assistant Scoutmaster role, and more explicit troop program and advancement machinery. The book still teaches the patrol method while building more machinery around it.10

    Hillcourt should not be cast as a Baden-Powell purist on troop structure. While his enduring focus on patrols is commendable, he tried to keep patrol vitality alive inside a growing troop-level architecture that he did not challenge. His own materials presupposed that architecture: Senior Patrol Leader, troop officers, Troop Leaders’ Council, Green Bar Patrol, and the troop-meeting-centered rhythm.

    While the 1936 version remains patrol-centered, it furthers the formal troop machinery that later overgrows the patrol.

    By 1959, troop offices had grown heavier

    The 1959 Scoutmaster’s Handbook still has the right official center of gravity. Its strongly affirms the patrol method with11:

    The Scoutmaster’s FIRST Job: Helping boy leaders make the PATROL METHOD work and to work with and through responsible adults to give Scouting to boys.

    Direction to Scoutmasters that affirms the patrol method.

    It also says the patrol method is an “absolute necessity” and affirms the adult-association method by asserting that freeing the Scoutmaster from details so that “above all, you have time to help each individual boy in the troop through frequent personal contacts”.12

    However, the 1959 handbook reveals that the troop-office architecture had grown heavier. The Senior Patrol Leader is described as the troop’s highest elected office and executive officer. Assistant Senior Patrol Leaders relieve the SPL of details. “Troop warrants”, formal recognition of youth officeholders, extend to Instructor, Junior Assistant Scoutmaster, Scribe, Quartermaster, Librarian, Den Chief, and other offices. The Patrol Leader’s transmission-belt role is also clearer: he represents his patrol in the Patrol Leaders’ Council, brings ideas from the patrol, and carries the accepted program back to the patrol for action.13

    Reaffirming this is mixed language. Despite language asserting the primacy of patrols, described above, other language conflates the patrol method with running the troop, such as “letting your boy leaders run THEIR troop”.14 This reveals a growing the tension about which gets primacy, the patrols or the troop. Is the program about the patrol method, or is it about the troop-level bureaucracy?

    While this book still argues for the patrol method, it furthers the administrative structure that would later overpower it.

    Advancement wired offices into rank

    In 1965, advancement gave the office machinery credentialing force. BSA’s own On Scouting summary says the “Revised Boy Scout Advancement Plan” took effect on October 1, 1965, and required Scouts to serve in positions of responsibility as part of rank advancement. A rank-history chart compiled from Boy Scout handbooks identifies Star, Life, and Eagle requirements in 1965 as requiring service as a troop “warrant officer”, which today is called a “position of responsibility”. Patrol Leader was included, but only as one position in a list that also included several other roles.15

    The list later evolved into something even more revealing. Today, for credentialing purposes, leading a patrol counts the same as maintaining the troop’s website. Assistant Patrol Leader, the only other titled, patrol-level role, counts for nothing.16 The advancement affirmed the troop-office layer.

    Youth-facing books taught the machinery

    The 1967 Patrol Leader’s Handbook confirms the troop-level focus. Its Patrol Leader’s Code, after listing personal and patrol-centric duties, says that, as a “leader in my troop”, the Patrol Leader should “[t]ake an active part in the patrol leaders’s council”, “[s]ee that the patrol is prepared to take an active part in all troop activities”, and “[w]ork with the Scoutmaster and other troop leaders to make the troop run well”.17

    This isn’t about participating in a congress of patrols in a patrol-centric troop. Other parts of this book make clear that this is subsuming considerable parts of the Patrol Leader function into the troop-level machinery, such as working with the SPL in “plan[ning] the troop activities and mak[ing] sure they are carried out”18, that the Patrol Leader has a “share” of “[t]aking charge of the troop”19, conformance with a “troop … budget plan” and with a youth-staffed, bureaucratic finance apparatus,20 that activities run by a patrol on behalf of a troop are decided by the PLC and announced by the SPL21, that the agenda of the PLC is set by the SPL-“chairman” and Scoutmaster22, that the Patrol Leader is a transmission belt for planning that emerges from the PLC23, and more. The focus is on the troop, not the patrols.

    The same 1967 youth-facing handbook gives the Patrol Leaders’ Council a parliamentary meeting structure. The Senior Patrol Leader chairs, the troop scribe keeps minutes, other troop leaders attend when their work is being planned, and the council holds annual and monthly planning meetings to build the troop program. It even warns that patrol hikes must not conflict with troop activities, because “the patrols must be present” for a troop function.24 That is youth-facing bureaucratization.

    The 1972 Scout Handbook, also youth-facing, carries the office-and-council model into the Improved Scouting Program era. It tells youth that the troop leaders’ council makes troop plans with help from the Scoutmaster and that, through that council, the Patrol Leader becomes the patrol’s voice in what the troop does.25

    The same 1972 youth handbook also describes an elected Senior Patrol Leader who sees that things happen in meetings and activities, chairs the troop leaders’ council, attends troop-committee meetings, may appoint an assistant, and may appoint Scouts to various troop-level roles.26

    The new-to-1972 feature was neither the youth-facing description of bureaucracy nor the bureaucracy’s advancement link. It was the concrete packaging of the bureaucracy.

    By 1981, the troop chart became the operating model

    The 1981 Official Scoutmaster Handbook, Seventh Edition, confirms the same emphasis. Its table of contents puts “Troop Organization and the Patrol Leaders’ Council” before “The Patrol Method,” then places Advancement, Training Junior Leaders, and Troop Administration inside a later section called “Tools to Do the Job.”27 It elevates the SPL to “the ‘big shot’ of the troop.”28

    The 1981 adult-leader handbook repeats the Patrol Leader’s troop-serving role in job-description form: the Patrol Leader is to “[p]repare [the] patrol to take part in all troop activities” and “[w]ork with other troop leaders to make the troop run well”.29 This is not mostly autonomous patrols. The patrol is just a cog in a troop machine.

    The focus of the troop is also clarified by the troop organization chart30, which is below. Here, gold loopers now mainly define a troop as a roster of troop-level officers. Patrols do not even appear on the chart. Patrol Leaders sit on the bottom tier of a chain of command. Notably, the chart almost entirely routes ordinary mentoring through the troop’s youth offices. Direct adult association, key to Baden-Powell’s patrol method, is displaced to scheduled set-pieces, like the Scoutmaster conference. With how these conferences are conveyed, they amount to a sideshow scheduled at the convenience of the Scoutmaster31, considerably different than Baden-Powell’s vision of adults as “older brother[s]” in a “jolly fraternity”.32

    Troop organization chart, as recommended by the 1981 Scoutmaster’s Handbook, Seventh Edition.

    The above diagram shows a Patrol Leaders’ Council (PLC), indicated by the heavy lines. The PLC amplifies the drift. The PLC is an administrative board, implemented as a bureaucratic committee, whose main point is “to plan and run the troop’s activities and to train the patrol leaders”.33 It “runs the troop through democratic representation of the patrols”.34

    This drives the point home: Patrol programs now exist at the whim of a troop-level bureaucratic structure. No longer leaders of independent teams, Patrol Leaders are diminished to just having a seat at the table in a bureaucratic committee. This often means patrols are reduced to labor pools. Patrol identity revolves around doing the chores described previously or doing activities ordered by the PLC.

    The “suggested order of business” for a PLC meeting emphasizes the bureaucratic nature of this committee35:

    The bureaucratic nature of the Patrol Leaders’ Council, as revealed in a recommended agenda in the 1981 The Official Scoutmaster Handbook, Seventh Edition.

    Note what isn’t on this agenda: any patrol’s own adventure. It is a production meeting for troop output.

    1972 gave the machine a theory of itself

    The popular account treats 1972 as the original sin. Gold loopers weakened outdoor requirements. A few years later, Hillcourt later restored the outing to Scouting. That is where the story often ends.

    The outdoor-program grievance is real. It also crowds out the structural grievance. The handbook progression above shows the troop-office machinery was already built, youth-facing, and wired into advancement. Gold loopers used the 1972 Improved Scouting Program to ratify that six-decade trajectory.

    What 1972 added was a theory of the machinery. The Improved Scouting Program was gold loopers’ broad overhaul of “every aspect of the Scout program”.36 It made the troop-office layer look like pedagogy. Office-holding was no longer merely administrative scaffolding. The office became the lesson.

    White Stag, a Monterey Bay Area Council leadership-training experiment that predated the Improved Scouting Program, belongs in that 1972 context because it explains how the drift could be mistaken for leadership training rather than admitted as a retreat from patrol ownership. White Stag’s founder, Béla Bánáthy, and its program gave BSA the Eleven Skills of Leadership, a language of formal competencies and intentional training design.37

    Gold loopers studied that approach, adapted it into Wood Badge, and later credited White Stag in the Troop Leader Development Staff Guide.38 Gold loopers’ own 1972 report to Congress says the new Wood Badge syllabus concentrated on leadership development for Scoutmasters, with youth-facing Troop Leader Development was being tested at Schiff and Philmont.39

    Hillcourt resisted the shift from Scoutcraft to leadership competencies. White Stag’s history says John Larson reported that Hillcourt “fought us all the way,” that Hillcourt proposed a camping-oriented alternative, and that Chief Scout Executive Joseph Brunton approved Larson’s leadership-development plan instead.40 Hillcourt was contesting how the troop-office machine would be used: as support for Scoutcraft and patrol life, rather than as an explicit leadership-competency curriculum. Gold loopers chose the latter.

    Gold loopers then carried the same theory down to youth training through Troop Leader Development. The 1974 staff-guide material traced the leadership-development concept through social-science studies, Army noncommissioned-officer experiments, White Stag, Wood Badge testing beginning in 1967, junior-leader expansion in 1969, a 1971 Philmont test, full Wood Badge integration in 1972, and use in every council beginning in 1973.41

    Alongside that overhaul came the Leadership Corps, a new upper-age service layer. It assembled 14- and 15-year-old “[p]otential leaders” to serve the troop as bureaucrats and instructors. The Senior Patrol Leader ran that group.42 That is a revealing design. The older and more experienced Scouts were chiefly organized as a troop-staffing layer, an age-span problem taken up in part 5.

    The same turn appeared in BSA’s youth-facing Patrol and Troop Leadership. With chapters on the patrol, the troop, troop operation, troop leaders’ council meetings, and the Leadership Corps, that book was part of the same early-1970s turn.43 Before this turn, a Quartermaster could be understood as someone who kept the gear sorted. After this turn, being Quartermaster could be framed as practicing leadership competencies. The bureaucracy acquired a curriculum.

    The office-and-training machinery survived the rollback

    Much of the 1972 program was later reversed. By 1978, gold loopers had largely scrapped some of their Improved Scouting Program.44 They turned to William Hillcourt to author the new Scout handbook that restored an emphasis on the outdoors.45

    But restoring outdoor emphasis did not restore the patrol method. Gold loopers put camping and Scoutcraft back into the handbook while preserving their corporate-bureaucracy simulation.

    This may be the most compelling evidence that the corporate-bureaucracy simulation’s survival was not an accident. The broader framework survived because gold loopers had sold it as “leadership development”, tested it, evaluated it, and integrated it into training. White Stag’s historical material says an outside evaluator compared BSA’s leadership-development methods favorably with the best leadership-development programs available to managers.46

    Hold on: the outside benchmark for Scouting’s “leadership development” was the best training available to managers? That is a confession! The design center was managerial training, which is not leadership, and the structure gold loopers built around it behaves accordingly. That makes the managerial character of the program hard to miss.

    That is why “corporate-bureaucracy simulation” is the right name. Gold loopers’ structure did the work: a senior youth manager, assistants managers, department-like offices, chains of command, reports, training, troop-wide production, and high-school-aged Scouts typically made to keep the machine running.

    The current roster still reproduces the machine

    Current Scouts BSA materials still show the same center of gravity. Official troop-position materials list a familiar roster of youth positions.47 The Senior Patrol Leader is treated as the troop’s top youth office and primary link between Scouts and adults.48 The Patrol Leaders’ Council is described as the troop’s governing body.49

    The roster has power because positions of responsibility are tied to advancement. Star and Life require months in one or more listed positions of responsibility unless the Scout completes a Scoutmaster-approved “leadership project”.50 Eagle removes that project alternative.51 The recognized-position requirement remains. Once advancement depends on recognized offices, the troop-level bureaucracy becomes immortal: Adults feel pressure to keep offices available. Scouts feel pressure to occupy them. The troop chart becomes a credentialing system even when the patrol method needs none of those offices.

    Adult training teaches the simulation, not the patrol method

    The adult-training problem is part of the same story. While it continues to wave at the patrol method, adult training’s emphasis is on the corporate-bureaucracy simulation.

    A key example comes from Montclair State University’s Building Evidence in Scouting Together (BEST) study of Scoutmaster Position-Specific Training, part of what allows Scoutmasters and Assistant Scoutmasters to be considered trained. The official syllabus treats the patrol method as required content. In the observed in-person courses, researchers found “zero instances” of trainers reinforcing the patrol method, even though they were instructed to do so!52

    This finding makes sense. This is not just a practical response to time limitations. Given the prioritization and complexity of the corporate-bureaucracy simulation, when something must give to teach this simulation, trainers appear incentivized to skip the very thing that gold loopers have paved over: the patrol method.

    (The BEST study was produced in collaboration with and is promoted by BSA53 and was funded by Stephen Bechtel Jr., a major Scouting donor and namesake of the Summit Bechtel Reserve.)

    Wood Badge makes adults rehearse the machine

    In BSA culture, Wood Badge is often treated as the mark of serious adult formation. BSA describes Wood Badge as an advanced national leadership course covering topics common with managers, such as conflict management, coaching, and project planning.54

    Wood Badge is delivered as a five-day55 practical course, often run over two weekends, in which adults live inside a model Scouts BSA troop, living inside the corporate-bureaucracy simulation. They treat that simulation as the framework for practicing program skills.56

    The objection is not that adults receive training. Adults need formation, knowledge, and practice mentoring youth. Wood Badge’s problem is the structure it normalizes. Its model troop teaches adults to inhabit the corporate-bureaucracy simulation that gold loopers built: troop offices, troop-wide coordination, management language, and a youth bureaucracy treated as the normal operating system.

    Enormous documentation

    The lengthy Wood Badge dress rehearsal is just part of it.

    The Scouts BSA corporate-bureaucracy simulation is so complicated that the official BSA reference for program-side adult leaders in troops (Scoutmaster and Assistant Scoutmasters), the Troop Leader Guidebook, is two volumes. Together, these volumes are 338 pages and 180,738 words.

    By comparison, the U.S. Constitution, with all its amendments, is only 7,591 words.

    The patrol method is simple

    The patrol method needs no immersion course, no mind-bogglingly long documentation, because it fits in four sentences!

    Even Hillcourt, despite working inside gold loopers’ growing troop-level architecture, could still describe the older simplicity of the patrol method57:

    If you want to be a Scout, you go and make up a patrol and go out and do scouting. That’s all it says in the early books in those days.

    It was the out-of-doors, scouting and camping. The ideals also. The life of a small patrol in the out-df-doors with the campfires. That was the real appeal to me.

    William Hillcourt musing on his experiences as a youth.

    The next article turns from the historical buildout to the machinery itself: the official troop offices and positions of responsibility that move patrol work upward and turn youth bureaucracy into the apparent center of Scouts BSA.

    Footnotes

    1. Handbook for Scout Masters, First Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1913 & 1914, p. 22. ↩︎
    2. Ibid, p. 22. ↩︎
    3. Handbook for Scout Masters, First Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1913 & 1914, p. 68. ↩︎
    4. Ibid, pp. 115, 118-119, 142. ↩︎
    5. Handbook for Scoutmasters: A Manual for Leadership, Second Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1922, p. 17. The title page says this is the “third imprint”. ↩︎
    6. Ibid, p. 255. ↩︎
    7. Ibid, p. 17. ↩︎
    8. Ibid, p. 17. ↩︎
    9. Scouting’s Barriers to Abuse, Scouting America. Current policy prohibits one-on-one contact between adult leaders and youth members and requires two registered adult leaders at all Scouting activities. ↩︎
    10. Handbook for Scoutmasters, Volume One, Third Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1938, pp. vi, 2-3, 130-132, 191-208. The copyright page indicates that the first imprint was in 1936. William Hillcourt’s authorship is mentioned on p. vi. ↩︎
    11. Scoutmaster’s Handbook, Fifth Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1959, p. 32. ↩︎
    12. Ibid, pp. 40, 42. ↩︎
    13. Ibid, pp. 48-57. The handbook describes the Patrol Leader as both patrol leader and troop leader, describes the Senior Patrol Leader and Assistant Senior Patrol Leader, and lists troop warrants for youth offices. ↩︎
    14. Ibid, p. 40. ↩︎
    15. Bryan Wendell, One surprising fact about anyone who earned Eagle before Oct. 1, 1965, On Scouting, Dec. 27, 2021. (On Scouting is a recent, new brand for the online versions of Scouting and Scout Life magazines.) See also Jeff Snowden, BSA Rank Advancement Requirements, 1910-2019, Troop 97, Fort Collins, Colorado, updated Sept. 2019, pp. 9-10. ↩︎
    16. Star Rank Requirements, Life Rank Requirements, Eagle Rank Requirements, Boy Scouts of America. See the requirement in each that mentions “positions of responsibility”. ↩︎
    17. Patrol Leader’s Handbook, Boy Scouts of America, 1967, p 10. ↩︎
    18. Ibid, p. 7. ↩︎
    19. Ibid, p. 7. ↩︎
    20. Ibid, p. 14. ↩︎
    21. Ibid, p. 43. ↩︎
    22. Ibid, p. 63. ↩︎
    23. Ibid, p. 64. ↩︎
    24. Ibid, p. 89. ↩︎
    25. Scout Handbook, Boy Scouts of America, 1972, p. 26. ↩︎
    26. Ibid, pp. 22, 26-27. ↩︎
    27. The Official Scoutmaster Handbook, Seventh Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1981, pp. 4-5. The table of contents places troop organization and the Patrol Leaders’ Council before the patrol method, and later lists advancement, junior-leader training, and troop administration as tools to do the job. ↩︎
    28. The Official Scoutmaster Handbook, Seventh Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1981, p. 52. ↩︎
    29. Ibid, p. 51. ↩︎
    30. Ibid, p. 49. ↩︎
    31. Ibid, pp. 23-24. ↩︎
    32. Robert Baden-Powell, Aids to Scoutmastership, 1944, p. 3. ↩︎
    33. The Official Scoutmaster Handbook, Seventh Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1981, p. 54. ↩︎
    34. Ibid, p. 54. ↩︎
    35. Ibid, p. 55. ↩︎
    36. Annual Report to Congress, Boy Scouts of America, 1972, pp. 8, 21-22.. ↩︎
    37. Béla H. Bánáthy, Founder of the White Stag Leadership Development Program, White Stag Leadership Development. The page describes Bánáthy as a systems scientist and founder of White Stag. See also The Eleven Skills of Leadership, White Stag Leadership Development. ↩︎
    38. U.S. Boy Scouts Adapted the White Stag Program, White Stag Leadership Development. ↩︎
    39. Annual Report to Congress, Boy Scouts of America, 1972, pp. 21-22. ↩︎
    40. U.S. Wood Badge Origins in White Stag, White Stag Leadership Development. ↩︎
    41. Troop Leadership Development’s Origins in White Stag, White Stag Leadership Development. The page reproduces material from the 1974 Troop Leader Development Staff Guide, pp. 94-95. ↩︎
    42. The Official Scoutmaster Handbook, Seventh Edition, Boy Scouts of America, 1981, pp. 50, 63-65. While not a primary source for this article, Leadership Corps (1972-89), Senior Scouting History, is worth a review. This summarizes the 1972 Leadership Corps program, including older Scouts serving as troop leaders and instructors. It has some information not corroborated by the 1981 Scoutmaster Handbook, such as the theory that Patrol Leaders are excluded from the Leadership Corps. ↩︎
    43. Patrol and Troop Leadership, Boy Scouts of America, 1972. ↩︎
    44. Lawrence van Gelder, “A Work of Love for ‘Boy Scout,’ 78“, The New York Times, Feb. 4, 1979. ↩︎
    45. Robert W. Peterson, “Bill Hillcourt — Still Going Strong on the Scouting Trail,” Scouting, vol. 73, no. 4 (Sept. 1985), p. 26. ↩︎
    46. Troop Leadership Development’s Origins in White Stag, White Stag Leadership Development. The page reproduces material from the 1974 Troop Leader Development Staff Guide, pp. 94-95; it says an outside evaluator compared BSA’s leadership-development methods favorably with leadership-development programs available to managers in public and private organizations. ↩︎
    47. Troop Positions, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    48. Senior Patrol Leader, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    49. Patrol Leader’s Council Monthly Planning, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    50. 2025 Scouts BSA Requirements, Boy Scouts of America, 2025, pp. 17-22. ↩︎
    51. Ibid. ↩︎
    52. Implementing the BSA Scoutmaster Training Model as Designed: A Fidelity Assessment, Montclair State University, July 2019. ↩︎
    53. https://bsabeststudy.org/ ↩︎
    54. Wood Badge, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    55. Bryan Wendell, “Inside the Wood Badge update that makes the program more accessible than ever“, Scouting Magazine, September 2020. ↩︎
    56. Wood Badge 2025, Suffolk County Council, Boy Scouts of America. The page describes the practical phase as conducted as a troop and using a model Scouts BSA troop as the foundation for training. ↩︎
    57. Lawrence van Gelder, “A Work of Love for ‘Boy Scout,’ 78“, The New York Times, Feb. 4, 1979. ↩︎
  • The patrol method is not a youth bureaucracy

    The patrol method is not a youth bureaucracy

    The patrol method is not complicated. That is its strength.

    The patrol method–the core of Scouting–means small teams of youth pursuing adventures they actually own, with adult support. That’s really it.

    Genuine leadership happens there: in the patrol, not in a youth-operated troop bureaucracy or a management structure staffed by youth wearing officer patches.

    While BSA’s gold loopers1 still use “patrol method” when talking about the Scouts BSA program, they are using the words while abandoning the thing. Over the past century, gold loopers have mostly paved over the patrol method, filling that space with a corporate-bureaucracy simulation.

    Before I go on, some level setting:

    Scouts BSA’s focus has strayed far from youth leading self-governing patrols. Instead, the focus is on youth filling bureaucratic roles in an adult-authored, troop-level structure.

    Series note: This is part one of a five-part series on how BSA’s gold loopers stole the patrol method, replacing it with a corporate-bureaucracy simulation. (The next articles will be published in a few days.)

    Part 2: How the troop bureaucracy acquired a leadership theory
    Part 3: How troop positions of responsibility steal patrol ownership
    Part 4: Adults must stop hiding behind youth offices
    Part 5: High schoolers are not troop staff

    What the patrol owns

    A patrol is more than a seating chart or a camping subunit. Again, it a small team of youth pursuing adventures they actually own.

    BSA’s material describes a patrol as a small team where youth “learn skills together, share responsibilities and take on leadership roles”.2 World Scouting treats the “Scout Method”3 (its equivalent to “patrol method”) as an “essential and unique system for progressive self-education”4.

    The patrol method is the timeless vision of Scouting’s founder, Robert Baden-Powell5:

    The Patrol System is the one essential feature in which Scout training differs from that of all other organizations, and where the System is properly applied, it is absolutely bound to bring success. It cannot help itself!

    Robert Baden-Powell, Aids to Scoutmastership, 1920 edition

    It is also visible in BSA’s international peer organizations. The exact wording varies, but the center of gravity is familiar: patrols do the program, adults support. For example:

    • Scouting Ireland says the troop program should be based around “Patrol based adventure and interaction”, that camp should be patrol based, and that Scouts should decide and organize their own program while working in patrols with adult support.6
    • Scouts Australia says the patrol method “is integral to Scouting” and that “[v]irtually all Scouting activities occur in Patrols”.7
    • The Scout Association in the United Kingdom says patrols “should be able to conduct their weekly programme on their own” with “adult[s] providing advice and guidance where needed”.8

    The adult-support point is crucial. The patrol method is not youth isolation. In BSA terminology, the support comes through “adult association”9: adults close enough to guide and restrained enough not to own the result.

    Scouts BSA’s own aims and methods point the same way. Leadership development is the only item that appears both as an aim and as a method.10 The patrol method develops leadership because it gives small teams the space for real decisions, real peer influence, and real consequences.

    The patrol is the natural unit of action

    No ordinary group of youth, handed a blank page and a trail map, would invent a corporate-bureaucracy simulation. They would invent a patrol. A leader would emerge. They would choose a destination, argue about what would make the trip worth doing, decide how bold they want to be, and come home with a story that belongs to them. They will stumble. That is part of the work. The patrol method gives them a real space in which to try.

    That instinct sits near the beginning of Scouting. Baden-Powell wrote about the natural youth gang as raw material for Scouting11, and Ernest Thompson Seton likewise built from the tendency of boys to form groups1213.

    Seton’s Woodcraft Indians program formalized that instinct into small bands, which were essentially patrols, with their own youth leaders and adult guides. (Some cross-band youth roles also existed, but they supported the patrols in rotating, episodic terms, such as during a campout. They were not a lasting bureaucracy that replaced small-team ownership.)14

    This is much of the magic of the patrol method: personal development by harnessing a natural tendency of youth.

    The patrol is the unit of action. It is where a Scout with a vision has to motivate actual peers, not simply occupy a titled office inside a bureaucratic structure devised by gold loopers.

    The troop exists to support patrols

    The patrol method means Scouts acting through small, self-directed teams. It does not mean youth filling offices in a troop-wide administrative chart.

    The patrol method places the spotlight on patrol programs, not troop machinery. The troop supports the patrol method by being a container for patrols and a support structure around them. It is not supposed to be the operating unit that consumes patrol autonomy.

    That said, the support of patrol autonomy still needs guardrails. A working troop has safety expectations, adult availability, transportation limits, calendar realities, facility reservations, and shared patrol commitments. However, those limits come from practical necessity, not obedience to a youth bureaucracy.

    For example, the Patrol Leaders and Scoutmaster might agree that the troop will host a campout at Tyler State Park in October and that all patrols will share a Saturday evening meal. That facility and meal choice will bound the option space for patrol adventures. This bounding is a result of the decision of the patrols, and the remaining option space is expansive, allowing real patrol autonomy.

    The simple test is this: Who gets to answer the patrol’s real questions? What adventure do we want to attempt? What would make this ours? What risks are we ready to manage? What help should we ask from adults? Which mistakes are ours to learn from? What traditions and habits do we want to build?

    If those questions are answered by a troop bureaucracy before the patrol ever asks them, the patrol method has been stolen. And that is what the next article will help us see, the gradual theft of the patrol method and how it was replaced with a troop-level youth bureaucracy.

    A council of patrol leaders is not troop staff

    Some will point to Baden-Powell’s own council of Patrol Leaders as evidence of troop-level staffing. That council was not a troop staff meeting. It was Patrol Leaders guarding collective standards and settling inter-patrol questions while each patrol kept its own program.15 Authority flowed up, from the patrols, into this council from the patrols.

    In the gold-loopers’ Scouts BSA corporate-bureaucracy simulation, the PLC inverts that authority. The modern PLC is where a Senior Patrol Leader chairs a standing committee whose stated purpose is to “review[…] and carr[y] out” the “troop’s plans”16 (emphasis added), and patrols then share in execution of PLC decisions alongside troop-level youth bureaucrats.

    Baden-Powell’s PLC was patrols in congress. BSA’s PLC is operation of a corporate bureaucracy.

    The semantic fate of “court of honor” tells the same story. In Baden-Powell’s formulation, the court of honor was a narrower form of the Patrol Leaders’ Council, intended to handle the more thorny issues, such as advancement and discipline. Advancement and discipline are now adult-managed, and that is appropriate.17 However, this name survives today as a ceremony to hand out patches.18 The disappearance of the original court of honor function is a symptom of a larger shift, which requires us to ask, “What meaningful responsibility remains for Patrol Leaders and patrols, especially beyond contributing to planning troop activities and supplying labor to a troop-level youth bureaucracy?”

    Gold loopers stole the patrol method from youth

    In the Scouts BSA program, we often see teams that cook together, camp together, make duty rosters, clean gear, and solve ordinary camp problems. We mistakenly believe this is evidence of the patrol method.

    While those chores are necessary, they are not proof that the patrol method is being used. An adult can point to Scouts planning a menu and still miss the deeper thing: patrol self-government.

    The patrol method depends on the patrol having meaningful control over its own life. The patrol should be able to form its identity, choose its adventure, make its arrangements, develop its habits, and live with the consequences.

    The question is not whether a team is performing chores together. Essential to the patrol method is that the patrol owns its adventure.

    Gold loopers stole the patrol method from BSA’s youth. Their design for the Scouts BSA program displaces the patrol method with a corporate-bureaucracy simulation19:

    The teams are still there, and they are still called patrols. That is why Scouts BSA can appear to preserve patrol-method vocabulary even though the patrol’s crucial self-government opportunity is hollowed out.

    The patrol flag remains. The patrol name remains. The patch remains. The chores remain. But gold loopers captured the patrols, moving the center of decision-making into a troop-level youth bureaucracy. They eviscerated the very thing Baden-Powell said the patrol method exists to do20:

    The object of the Patrol System is mainly to give real responsibility to as many of the boys as possible with a view to developing their character. If the Scoutmaster gives his Patrol Leader real power, expects a great deal from him, and leaves him a free hand in carrying out his work, he will have done more for that boy’s character expansion than any amount of school-training could ever do.

    Robert Baden-Powell’s reflection on the point of patrols in Aids to Scoutmastership, 1919 edition (emphasis added).

    Leadership is influence, not administration

    The Patrol Leader is supposed to be the leader of a largely self-governing patrol. That means this youth helps turn the patrol’s own will into action: drawing out a vision, persuading peers, coordinating preparation, settling friction, noticing who needs help, and keeping the patrol moving toward a shared purpose.

    The Patrol Leader’s authority is peer-based leadership. This is trust, competence, and respect inside the patrol, not a titled slot inside a troop chain of command.

    The Scouts BSA corporate-bureaucracy simulation changes the Patrol Leader’s work. Instead of leading a semi-autonomous patrol, the Patrol Leader becomes a transmission belt inside a troop machine: attend the PLC21, receive the troop plan, relay it to the patrol, supply labor for troop activities, report upward, and keep the patrol aligned with decisions made elsewhere.

    Management keeps the institution running. Supervision keeps people in line. Administration keeps the files straight. These are what the corporate-bureaucracy simulation emphasizes.

    Leadership is different: it is mutual influence around a shared vision.

    That distinction is not some eccentric Scouting obsession. For example, Abraham Zaleznik‘s classic Harvard Business Review essay, “Managers and Leaders: Are They Different?”, contrasts the managerial concern for competence, control, and balancing groups with the imaginative, desire-driven work of leadership.22 Translate that into Scouts BSA, and the problem becomes obvious. The corporate-bureaucracy simulation gives adults the neat surface of management. The patrol method, which gold loopers paved over, gives youth the messy social space where leadership can actually form.

    Administration does not become leadership because youth do it

    Competence with the English language can help one be a better plumber, yet it would be absurd to claim that high-school English classes constitute training for plumbers. The same goes for administration, management, and supervision: they are not leadership. While training in those competencies can have value to leaders, they do not cause a person to become a leader.

    A Scout can chair a meeting, direct traffic, enforce a schedule, assign tasks, or take minutes without practicing leadership. Those actions may be useful. They may even be necessary in a bureaucracy. But usefulness does not make them leadership.

    Nor does foisting troop-level administrative duties on youth, especially in the sense of lasting, titled roles, cause leadership development. Those tasks can be useful. A particular older youth might even want some of them as an additional challenge. But just because a youth occupies that titled role does not transform it into leadership.

    Also, there is nothing essential to Scouting that requires troop-level administration to sit at the center of any youth’s experience. What this mainly does is redirect youth attention out of the leadership-oriented patrol experience towards troop-level bureaucratic concerns, and it removes from patrols the decision points that make self-directed teams real.

    Even worse, this troop-level youth bureaucracy stands in for adult mentoring, filtering it through a youth-run, supervisory chain of command.

    None of this enhances BSA’s mission to develop leaders.

    When adults snort, “But the youth lead the troop,” they have not answered the charge. They have repeated the problem. Instead of being provided leadership opportunity, the youth were presented with a bureaucratic scheme and told to operate it.

    The burden of proof belongs on gold loopers

    In BSA culture, those who doubt gold loopers are treated with disdain. This culture puts the burden of proof on supporters of the patrol method, requiring them to explain why they resist the corporate-bureaucracy simulation. That has it backwards, and the burden should run in the other direction.

    Unlike the corporate-bureaucracy simulation, the patrol method has the founder’s warrant, remains recognizable in world Scouting, fits the natural way youth form small teams around shared adventures, and supports genuine leadership development. If gold loopers want to replace leadership development with a bureaucratic, troop-office scheme, the burden is on them to explain why their substitute is better.

    Gold loopers’ usual answer is that troop offices and positions of responsibility teach leadership. But a bureaucratic office does not become leadership merely because gold loopers say so. Gold loopers have mostly kept the patrol-method vocabulary while training Scouts and adults to operate something else.

    Adjacent programs show the shape

    The irony is that the programs on either side of Scouts BSA preserve the small-team shape better than Scouts BSA itself.

    Cub Scouts adapts the small-team pattern for younger children. Elementary-school children need adults much closer at hand, so the program is adult-led. But structurally, the den remains the small team, the Den Leader works directly with that team, and dens generally run independent programs.23

    Venturing adapts the same spirit for high schoolers. Adult Advisors advise rather than command24, and the crew design allow officer duties and team structure to vary with the crew’s needs.25 High schoolers can mentor within their own ranks: planning age-level adventures, apprentice younger high schoolers into real responsibility, and build a peer culture appropriate to their age.

    The next article follows the historical buildout of the Scouts BSA corporate-bureaucracy simulation, where gold loopers gradually built a troop-office machine, wired it into advancement, and then gave that machine a leadership-development theory.

    Footnotes

    1. Gold loopers are people associated with BSA’s national organization, which also includes territories, wear yellow shoulder loops on their uniforms. Formally, this color is called “gold”. While shoulder loops date only to the uniform redesign from around 1980, I apply the term retroactively to BSA’s national-level volunteers and professionals of every era. (Council and district adults, not a subject of this series, wear silver loops.) ↩︎
    2. The Patrol, Troop Leader Resources, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    3. Constitution of the World Organization of the Scout Movement, World Scout Bureau, August 2024 ed., Chap. I, Art. III, p. 7. The team system is a constitutional element of the Scout Method, agreed by all member organizations, including BSA. ↩︎
    4. Scout Method, World Scouting. ↩︎
    5. Robert Baden-Powell, Aids to Scoutmastership, 1944. p. 8. This is the World Brotherhood edition. Pagination is based on the digitized PDF copy with three columns. ↩︎
    6. How to Run Scouts, Scouting Ireland, pp. 21-22. ↩︎
    7. The Adventure Begins – Scout Method, Scouts Australia, Feb. 1, 2018. ↩︎
    8. Leadership, The Scout Association. ↩︎
    9. Scouts BSA: The Aims and Methods of Scouting, Boy Scouts of America. BSA lists “Association with Adults” as one of the methods of Scouts BSA. ↩︎
    10. Scouts BSA: The Aims and Methods of Scouting, Boy Scouts of America. BSA identifies leadership development as one of Scouting’s aims and also as one of the methods of Scouts BSA. ↩︎
    11. Robert Baden-Powell, Aids to Scoutmastership, 1944, p. 8. ↩︎
    12. David C. Scott, Ernest Thompson Seton: The Beginnings of Controversy, Scouting Milestones, curated by Colin Walker. ↩︎
    13. Ernest Thompson Seton, The Birch-Bark Roll, 6th Edition, 1906, p. 3. ↩︎
    14. Ernest Thompson Seton, The Book of Woodcraft, 1921, pp. 179-189. ↩︎
    15. Robert Baden-Powell, Aids to Scoutmastership, 1944, p. 8. ↩︎
    16. Patrol Leader’s Council Monthly Planning, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    17. This evolution is appropriate. The Barriers to Abuse places discipline under the Adult Supervision section. While the Guide to Advancement, 2025, permits limited youth involvement in selected advancement mechanics, it is always at the discretion of adults. For example, section 4.2.1.2 The Scout Is Tested leads with “The Scout’s unit leader authorizes those who may test and pass the Scout on rank requirements”, then lists selected, titled youth roles the unit leader might consider authorizing for this duty. ↩︎
    18. Troop Courts of Honor, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    19. Troop Structure, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    20. Robert Baden-Powell, Aids to Scoutmastership, 1919, p. 47. ↩︎
    21. Despite the name, the Patrol Leaders’ Council (PLC) does not focus on Patrol Leaders or patrols. The focus is on the troop-level machinery. Patrol Leader’s Council Monthly Planning, the main documentation for how this committee works, leads with “The troop’s plans…” ↩︎
    22. Abraham Zaleznik, Managers and Leaders: Are They Different?, Harvard Business Review, Jan. 2004. Zaleznik contrasts the managerial concern for competence, control, and balance with the imaginative work of leadership. ↩︎
    23. How Cub Scouting is Organized, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    24. Venturing Terminology, Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    25. Crew Officer Orientation: Facilitator’s Guide, Boy Scouts of America, 2025. ↩︎
  • OA’s tribal agreements are a fraud

    OA’s tribal agreements are a fraud

    Order of the Arrow, a branded operation of BSA, is known best for 111 years of redface minstrel shows.

    In an incomplete reform attempt, BSA now requires OA-branded council operations to stop some of their cultural theft, instead putting that cultural use under tribal purview. The purview is to be documented in a written agreement.

    I am using “fraud” in a public-accountability sense: while these agreements look like tribal oversight, they are really blanket permission slips, vague enough to let councils continue their OA-branded redface minstrel shows.

    OA’s identity is wrapped around over 111 years of its indigenous fraud. This is a powerful incentive for OA to perpetuate its redface minstrel show, so I always suspected we’d see flawed tribal agreements. I am right: all agreements to date are flawed.

    OA’s ethical problem

    One form of OA’s redface minstrel shows is where non-Native, teenage actors perform pageants based on OA’s fake “legend”, which is just Western children’s fantasy fiction. The legend has a phony Native connection, where OA decorated it with stolen and phony tribal culture. OA racist core is revealed in how it treats tribal culture like war trophies of conquered peoples.

    Many have been scammed by OA’s false claims of being an honor society or by its phony religion. The ensuing emotional connection drives aggressive, counterfactual defenses of OA. An example fake defense is that OA’s cosplay pageants are vital to preserving tribal culture.1 Others White-wash OA’s cultural theft as respect, honor, or appreciation of tribes.2 There’s more. No matter the defenses, OA’s ethic celebrates the intended outcome of the USA’s White-supremacist tribal-eradication campaign. Had the campaign been successful, we’d be in a dystopia where tribal culture is divorced from any sense of ownership, and non-Indigenous people would be needed to preserve tribal culture.

    Thankfully, the USA’s White-supremacist campaign failed. Tribes still exist.

    The naked truth is OA has always stolen tribal culture for its own profit. This profit is measured in coherence. With this stolen culture, OA concocts a faux, animist-pagan religion. This religion distracts everyone from how OA has no purpose, no reason to exist. Without its faux religion, OA’s absurdity becomes obvious, and OA collapses.

    This profit shows up in other facets of the OA redface minstrel show. For example, OA permits3 councils to name their OA operations—lodges and chapters—with words stolen from Indigenous peoples, often from the Lenape people.4 OA gets unearned gravitas from its use of these stolen words, similar to how military impostors benefit from stolen valor.

    OA’s intent

    In 2024, OA announced it will clean up some of its act, only allowing Indigenous-themed performances in councils that have a written agreement with a local state- or federally-recognized tribe.5 This policy went into effect on January 1, 2026.6

    Few councils have agreements. All of those agreements discovered as a press time are defective: they evade the intent of OA’s restriction, were struck with what federal tribes consider a phony entity, or both!

    OA intends that councils restrict AIA to what is authorized under a written agreement with a local7 tribe.

    In its AIA Policy page, OA says “[t]ribes may determine to what extent they want [councils] to conduct American Indian programming.”8 As it would be unethical for a tribe to authorize use of any other tribe’s culture, the most a tribe could authorize is use of that tribe’s own culture.

    OA further clarifies that councils “are free to pursue multiple agreements if they would like to offer a wider variety of programs that appreciate the different traditions in their area.”9 The only reason that OA would say that is because each tribe can only ethically authorize use of its own culture. Councils that wish to employ culture of additional tribes must reach an agreement with those tribes.

    To summarize, legitimate tribal agreements may only authorize councils to use the culture of the tribe they struck an agreement with. The ethics of this are obvious, and OA’s own words reinforce those ethics.

    Old Hickory Council evades intent

    Here’s an example agreement that Old Hickory Council struck with a tribe (names of the tribe and individuals, other than the council CEO, are redacted):

    This agreement does not restrict this council to using only the culture of the signing tribe. In fact, the first bullet’s phrase “the practices of the American Indian people vary from tribe to tribe” does a lot of work. It is a license to continue the old practices, where the council may freely steal from any tribe!

    As evidence of theft, Old Hickory Council’s OA operation is named “Wahissa Lodge”. While “wahissa” is likely a Lenape-derived word10, the agreement was signed with a group claiming Siouan heritage, a different branch of tribes that cannot ethically grant use of Lenape culture.

    In granting this unethical, universal license, the signing tribe gets little in return: an annual written report and “best efforts” to support an annual tribe event.

    The important point is how this agreement evades a key intent behind tribal agreements. It does not restrict the council to use of the signing tribe’s culture.

    Indian Waters Council evades intent

    Here’s another agreement, this time between the Indian Waters Council and a tribe11:

    Did you see that? It’s based on the same template! Look at the first bullet. The truck-sized loophole appears again, freely allowing resumption of OA’s 111 years of racist cultural theft. And the theft is laid out in the document, which indicates that Indian Water Council’s OA operation is named “Muscogee Lodge”. “Muscogee” is obviously a reference to the Muscogee people, yet this agreement was signed with an entity claiming Cherokee association.

    Just stammer “honor” and “respect”, and the redface minstrel show resumes!

    Indian Waters Council’s agreement with an allegedly phony tribe

    It gets worse. The “tribe” Indian Waters Council signed with appears on the Cherokee Identity Protection Committee’s list of fabricated groups.

    The Cherokee Identity Protection Committee, a collaboration of the three federally-recognized Cherokee tribes–Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians, Cherokee Nation, United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians–is a 2011 initiative to root out fake tribes. It compiled a list of 211 “fabricated groups” on what it calls a “Fraud List”.12 The Cherokee Nation’s Principal Chief has called these groups “phony”.13

    In this collaboration, these federal tribes “protect our elders and traditionalists by stopping these [fake tribes] and individuals from appropriating our culture, language and traditions.”14

    These tribes later released an forceful 2020 joint statement condemning what they consider to be phony tribes. One section also eviscerates OA’s 111 years of redface minstrel shows15:

    6)  We condemn all individuals and collectivities that ‘play Indian’ or ‘play Cherokee’ in all its forms, regardless of the intent.  This includes the widespread practice of forming fraudulent, so-called ‘state-recognized’ Cherokee tribes or nonprofit organizations that claim to confer Cherokee citizenship.  Non-Cherokees should never participate in Cherokee cultural expressions unless under the direct guidance of a Cherokee citizen.

    Put differently, these tribes are concerned about entities that, just like OA’s redface minstrel show, use stolen, native culture for their own profit. By entering into a loophole-ridden agreement with a tribe the Cherokees consider fake, the Indian Waters Council is perpetuating the act that the Cherokee tribes find deeply harmful!

    By entering into an agreement with an entity on a phony-tribes list, Indian Waters Council picked a side in a major dispute, and it picked the side the major Cherokee tribes find is eroding their tribal sovereignty.

    Native people and their advocates have warned me about this. Deciding what counts as a legitimate tribe, or who is a Native American, is complex. It is outside the scope of Scouting to weigh in on this, but these tribal agreements force us to do so. Why, though? Why does BSA permit councils to pick sides in a dispute that has nothing to do with Scouting? How does this help BSA do Scouting better?

    Northeast Georgia Council does “all of the above”

    Northeast Georgia Council provides another example of the duplicity of OA culture.

    This is the council’s tribal agreement16:

    The childish font and that the council didn’t publish a signed agreement reveal the unseriousness of this document. The words confirm its defective.

    First, this is yet another agreement with what the recognized Cherokee tribes have declared a phony entity. As per above, even if this entity is not a phony, by picking sides in this dispute, BSA enters a space it does not belong.

    Second, this agreement does not limit the lodge to use of any one tribe’s culture. With its soft, aspirational language; avoidance of clear words or phrases like “must”, “limited to” “shall only”, or similar; and no compliance mechanism, this agreement does not restrict which Native culture Northeast Georgia Council may use.

    Even worse, the first provision blesses OA’s 111 years of indigenous fraud as “a celebrated part of its programming”. That frames this agreement as continuity of OA’s racist pageantry, not a course correction.

    Other provisions confirm the above:

    • While provision 4 includes “more locally focused”, that is not a boundary, it’s just an aspirational emphasis.
    • Provision 5’s aspirational language is undercut by “the traditions of those Native Americans who were and are a part of the geographic area shared by both parties”. This is a permission slip for Northeast Georgia Council to use any tribe’s tradition as long as its current or historical territory vaguely corresponds to the council’s territory or broader Cherokee territory, which historically overlapped multiple states.

    North Florida Council also evades transparency

    I have called for OA to require transparency on tribal agreements. I insist they be posted on council websites. This is necessary because 111 years of OA’s racist sins, combined with a culture that foments aggressive lies about OA’s sins, eviscerates trust. Non-public agreements are as good as no agreement. Also, OA is about appreciating tribes, right? Why would councils want to hide an agreement that confirms its genuine appreciation of a tribe?

    North Florida Council validates my concern. I have received a firsthand account of this council from a concerned party who resides in the council. After learning that this council struck an agreement with a tribe, the concerned party asked a council-level person, who is one of several in a position to have access to this agreement, for a copy of it. The council person refused.

    Why? Because it’s another defective agreement!

    I want to be clear that the facts below are based on an account shared with me by the concerned party. This was apparently an oral conversation, so any quotes of the council person are paraphrased.

    First, the tribal agreement is with yet another entity that the federally-recognized Cherokee tribes find to be phony!

    Second, the council person conveyed the agreement has no end date, despite OA’s expectation that tribal agreements should “have a set duration”.17

    Third, this agreement has that same, truck-sized loophole of the other agreements. The council person attested to a belief that the agreement allows North Florida Council to continue naming its OA operation using a word the council appropriated from the Seminole people. This council person then twists the knife, undermining the Seminole tribe’s ownership of its own culture by stating (paraphrased) “there are a lot of people who wear Seminole-style jackets as fashion items!”

    The council person signed off from this conversation with a “trust me, bro”-style statement (again, paraphrased): “A Scout is Trustworthy. You can take my word for it and you don’t need to see the letter.”

    Sorry, bro, after 111 years of OA’s racist sins and lying, nothing associated with OA is trustworthy. No public agreement is as good as the agreement not existing.

    OA does not verify tribal agreements

    BSA’s national OA office doesn’t verify these agreements. Councils only “attest” to the existence of an agreement.18 It’s more “trust me, bro”, captured in a checkbox on an annual form.19

    In a conversation with a concerned person, a person affiliated with the National OA Committee implausibly conveyed that BSA does not have time to review tribal agreements. Sorry, that’s lazy. The National OA Committee is large, so they can review these agreements.20 The committee just doesn’t wish to.

    And I can understand why. The National OA Committee doesn’t do much work. For example, it took almost 5 years to revise children’s fantasy fiction!

    But the problem cuts more deeply. If the National OA Committee reviewed these agreements, they wouldn’t pass muster. But OA needs these agreements. OA is addicted to its redface minstrel show. It can’t stop. That’s why:

    • OA falsely claims reform while allowing loophole-ridden agreements.
    • OA falsely claims tribal oversight while refusing to verify agreements.
    • OA falsely claims “respect”, “honor”, etc. while continuing to steal Indigenous culture for use as institutional decoration.

    Retire it!

    OA is a fraud. OA is an embarrassment to Scouting.

    It gets worse. OA isn’t even a program of BSA.21 It’s just a branded operation, mainly run by councils, that has crept so far outside its lane, it cannibalizes and displaces the actual programs, and it helps trap high schoolers in a middle-school program. It maps poorly to what Scouting even is.

    Stated differently, OA is mainly a council-run prestige club that isn’t Scouting, that cannibalizes the very Scout units that councils are supposed to support, and that convinces high schoolers to willingly be infantilized.

    Why is anyone bothering to save this?

    OA must be retired. We must instead invest in the actual Scouting programs.

    1. (this is provided as a representative example) National Bulletin, Order of the Arrow, Issue 1, Volume LXII, Spring 2015. See page 9 where someone associated with a different country’s Scouting movement proclaims that “Native American history and legacy is preserved and honored by the [OA] Scouts”. Given that this person doesn’t live in the USA and is likely unfamiliar with OA, he was likely to have been told the preserving-culture scam by the redface minstrel show’s actors. ↩︎
    2. (this is provided as a representative example) Field Operations Handbook, Order of the Arrow, November 2025. Page 27 includes “Respect for American Indian culture, tradition, and heritage is a key component of Order of
      the Arrow programs.” ↩︎
    3. AIA Policy, Order of the Arrow. See section titled “Do lodges or chapters need to change their names, totems, or other items that use American Indian names or terms?” This section upholds the longstanding practice of decorating facets of OA with stolen tribal culture. ↩︎
    4. Order of the Arrow cleanliness audit. See the source data, linked below the graph. ↩︎
    5. “Policy Update: Changes Regarding American Indian Programming“, Order of the Arrow website, September 24, 2024. ↩︎
    6. Ibid. ↩︎
    7. AIA Policy, Order of the Arrow. Throughout the policy, “local” is exclusively used to define geographic limits on the tribe’s location. ↩︎
    8. AIA Policy, Order of the Arrow. See section titled “Will lodges be provided with a template or sample agreement needed to establish a relationship with their local tribe?” ↩︎
    9. Ibid. ↩︎
    10. Various clues suggest this is an Anglicized spelling of a Lenape word relating to goddess, beauty, or happiness. ↩︎
    11. Muscogee Ensures Future of AIA Program, Indian Waters Council (via its website for its OA operation, named Muscogee Lodge) ↩︎
    12. Matthew L.M. Fletcher, “Eastern Band Establishes Cherokee Identity Protection Committee“, Turtle Talk, October 17, 2011. While this article claims 212 entities, its data source lists 211. ↩︎
    13. https://www.facebook.com/chiefhoskin/posts/faketribealert-the-phony-wolf-creek-cherokee-tribe-of-virginia-is-back-i-look-fo/355873679871080/ ↩︎
    14. Ibid. ↩︎
    15. “Cherokee Scholars’ Statement on Sovereignty and Identity“, Think Tsalagi ᎢᏓᏓᏅᏛᎵ ᏣᎳᎩ, February 13, 2020. ↩︎
    16. A New Day… A New Era…, Northeast Georgia Council (through the website of its OA operation, named Mowogo Lodge) ↩︎
    17. AIA Policy, Order of the Arrow. See section titled “Will lodges be provided with a template or sample agreement needed to establish a relationship with their local tribe?” ↩︎
    18. AIA Policy, Order of the Arrow. See section titled “Who is responsible for maintaining the agreement between the lodge and the tribe?” ↩︎
    19. AIA Policy, Order of the Arrow. See section titled “How often does the agreement with a tribe need to be renewed?” ↩︎
    20. “National Order of the Arrow Committee“, from the Order of the Arrow website of the Boy Scouts of America. ↩︎
    21. Rules and Regulations of the Boy Scouts of America, October 28, 2025. At the top of page 12 is “The youth programs of the Boy Scouts of America are Cub Scouts, Scouts BSA, Venturing, Sea Scouts, and Lone Scout.” ↩︎
  • Scouting’s real crisis is not marketing. It is decades of neglect.

    Scouting’s real crisis is not marketing. It is decades of neglect.

    When the Boy Scouts of America, recently rebranded as Scouting America, gathers in Dallas May 11-15 for its National Annual Meeting, its leaders will confront a crisis that messaging cannot solve. At the end of 2025, the organization’s market share sank to about 1.25 percent of American youth, the lowest since about 1923. The organization has not strung together a multi-year recovery in 25 years.

    BSA’s decline is not the generic story of a youth organization losing ground to phones, sports, or overscheduling. Those affect everyone. BSA’s problem is more specific. Its historic advantages—brand recognition, inexpensive outdoor access, and the prestige of Eagle Scout—once masked program defects. As those advantages diminish, families see the defects more clearly.

    The obstacle is BSA’s national culture. Inside BSA, career advancement and volunteer appointments are too often detached from producing better youth programs. Instead, they are commonly prestige markers awarded to those who avoid candor. Accountability is optional; institutional deference is not. The result is a class of insiders who deny decline with cheerful press releases while treating internal critics as disloyal.

    This culture validates bad ideas. The clearest example is the program Americans still picture when they hear “Boy Scouts”: Scouts BSA, the tan-uniform program that runs from 10-year-old fifth-graders to high-school seniors. No school, sports league, or serious youth-development program would treat children leaving elementary school and young adults preparing to graduate as one developmental audience. BSA does.

    This pattern extends to BSA’s other programs. Cub Scouts makes fifth graders share a program that also accommodates kindergartners. Venturing and Sea Scouts run from eighth graders to 20-year-old adults. The pattern is not developmental clarity. It is administrative convenience.

    BSA is an outlier in world Scouting. International peer organizations typically use age spans of three to five years, and none merge middle schoolers and high schoolers into one program. Those age bands are where development moves fastest, and BSA chose to blur it.

    The cost falls on both ends of Scouts BSA. That program is optimal for middle schoolers, but middle schoolers are not trusted to own it. They are managed by older youth instead. High schoolers fare no better. Instead of receiving programming built around autonomy, peer challenge, advanced outdoor adventure, and responsibility suited to their age, the vast majority are trapped in a middle-school program where their main role is supervising the younger Scouts. BSA romanticizes this as mentoring. Teenagers see it as babysitting. They know the difference, and they leave.

    That culture’s deepest failure is conceptual. Leadership is a key Scouting promise, the only item common to its methods and aims, and the promise BSA often invokes to justify Eagle Scout1, youth offices2, patrols3, and adult training4. But leadership is not a patch. It is not a title, office, authority, or chain of command. Leadership is influence: persuading voluntary followers to move toward a shared vision for change.

    BSA has spent decades replacing leadership with administration. This substitution is evident in how BSA replaced the patrol method with a corporate-bureaucracy simulation. Widely used internationally, the patrol method is small, independent, self-governing teams of youth making real decisions, solving real problems, and learning through consequences. It centers on the patrol and Patrol Leader. Decades ago, BSA evicted the patrol method in favor of emerging corporate-management theories5. Patrols became roster slots inside a bureaucracy of titled youth roles, layered reporting6, meeting scripts7, and committee procedure8. BSA never stopped saying “patrol method.” It preserved the vocabulary while replacing the operating system.

    Wood Badge, the organization’s premier adult-training program, reinforces the substitution. Marketed as leadership training, it functions mainly as a bureaucrat-polishing school. Adults rehearse the corporate-bureaucracy simulation and return home to faithfully implement what undermines leadership development.

    The Eagle Scout rank illustrates the same drift. American society gives BSA an extraordinary gift: it treats Eagle as a distinction among high schoolers, a signal of maturity and leadership. BSA undercuts that gift. Eagle is just part of a middle-school advancement ladder, and 11-year-olds can earn it.9 Instead of certifying tested leadership, it often rewards advancement velocity, compliance, and tenure in bureaucratic titled offices. Its famous service project is mostly a worksheet exercise10, accompanied, tellingly, by no project-management training.

    The culture’s aversion to candor extends to public missteps. After emerging from a sexual-abuse bankruptcy, BSA rebranded itself “Scouting America.” The new name initializes to “SA,” common shorthand for sexual assault. National leadership appears to know: BSA forbids use of the SA acronym, and on its official volunteer forum, national bureaucrats censor SA. When an initialism-rich organization chooses an initialism-prone brand yet forbids the initialism, it admits competence and candor problems.

    The institutional priorities are visible elsewhere. BSA’s 2024 audited statements list about $329 million in debt, including roughly $186 million in bonds for a West Virginia facility that in 2023 was utilized 97 percent below expectations. And when Secretary of War Pete Hegseth threatened military support, BSA quickly abandoned DEI initiatives, discontinued the Citizenship in Society merit badge, and undid inclusive policies. While readers may disagree about those policies, the institutional lesson is clear: BSA can act fast when outside pressure threatens the convenience or prestige of its national bureaucrats. It does not act at all when youth flee its programs.

    Dallas is the moment for truth. A serious agenda would begin with admissions: middle-schoolers deserve ownership of their own program; high-schoolers deserve a program built for their life stage; the corporate-bureaucracy simulation must be evicted and the patrol method restored; adult training must focus on genuine leadership; Eagle’s public meaning is being squandered; and the new corporate brand is an unforced error. These are starting points, not the full agenda. None of this requires another pilot program. It requires leaders willing to name the problems in public.

    This hard work is unlikely. Reform at BSA follows a familiar arc: stalled for decades, then bungled when finally implemented. The admission of gay members and girls took this course. National leadership has convinced itself that doing little, offending no one, and appeasing every constituency will produce the turnaround it needs. It will not.

    The membership trendline does not care about institutional feelings. If national leadership will not eat a few sacred cows in Dallas, the organization will be eaten by its own irrelevance. Anything less than candor is cheerful packaging around continued neglect. And if inaction means high-schoolers will remain in a middle-school program to supervise younger youth, BSA should at least have the honesty to pay the babysitters.

    Continue the conversation

    Keep the discussion going by leaving a comment below or joining social-media groups friendly to discussing Scouting’s hard topics:

    1. This justification is typically in loose language, but a specific example is in BSA’s 2024 Report to the Nation, where Eagle Scouts are introduced as exemplifying character, leadership, and service. ↩︎
    2. In the Troop Positions page of the Troop Leader Resources website, BSA lists the 16 different titled roles for Scouts BSA. These are titled roles in a child-sized corporate-bureaucracy simulation. ↩︎
    3. In the Patrols page of the Troop Leader Resources website, BSA references the Brownsea Island experiment. There, BSA praises the patrol method as the “one essential feature” of Scouting. In the patrol method, patrols are largely independent, and Patrol Leaders are elevated, being mentored directly by the Scoutmaster. Ironically, BSA undermines this “one essential feature” with its corporate-bureaucracy simulation, which changes Scouts BSA from where “[t]he patrol is the unit of Scouting always” to the troop itself being the essential unit, with patrols buried under the bureaucracy. ↩︎
    4. For most, Wood Badge is seen as the ultimate adult-training goal. Regrettably, Wood Badge has been undermined, reduced to mainly training on how to act as a corporate middle-manager and an extensive dress rehearsal of the Scouts BSA corporate-bureaucracy simulation. ↩︎
    5. The White Stag initiative seems to have been especially influential on the Scouts BSA design. While its focus on the ways of corporate middle management has value, that is different than leadership. By confusing management with leadership, BSA has undermined its leadership training for youth and has misinformed generations of adult leaders. ↩︎
    6. The Troop Structure page of BSA’s Troop Leader Resources website reveals that troops are a complex, youth-run bureaucracy. This contrasts starkly to the patrol method, still practiced nearly universally in the rest of the world, which generally only has patrols and Patrol Leaders and no child-sized bureaucracy. ↩︎
    7. BSA’s model treats the troop meeting as a scripted, centrally coordinated procedure rather than as the natural expression of independent patrol life. Its Troop Meeting Agenda page of the Troop Leader Resources site illustrates this, describing the weekly troop meeting as something to be managed through “planning and preparation”, directs the Patrol Leaders’ Council to use a “Troop Meeting Planning Form” to keep the meeting “organized and productive”, and divides a standard meeting into prescribed components. The form further structures the meeting by activity, description, who will run each part, and time allocation. This is not objectionable merely because it is an agenda; the point is that the script is the central part of a bureaucracy-run agenda, subsuming independent patrols into a corporate simulation. ↩︎
    8. In the Patrol Leader’s Council Monthly Planning page of Troop Leader Resources, BSA shows the committee layer that squashed patrol life. The page defines the Patrol Leaders’ Council as a monthly body that “fine-tune[s]” the troop program, composed of titled officeholders and attended by a scribe who takes notes and keeps minutes. It calls the PLC the troop’s “elected and duly appointed governing body” and assigns it responsibility for the “planning, preparation, and presentation” of the troop program, with a meeting agenda and planning worksheets linked below. This is youth administration, not leadership. Under this corporate-bureaucracy simulation, Patrol Leaders are pulled into a troop-wide committee procedure, and patrols are diminished as components of a managed troop program. ↩︎
    9. The shortest path to Eagle is 19 months. A Cub Scout can switch to Scouts BSA upon earning the Arrow of Light badge. As long as the Arrow of Light is earned within 5 months of turning 10, then that Scout can earn Eagle as an 11-year-old. ↩︎
    10. The Eagle Scout Service Project Workbook is a 32-page PDF that is often accompanied by additional materials. The Eagle candidate can easily spent many more hours on paperwork exercises than in the project itself. ↩︎